But a lover of controversial
wrangling catches up the argument, on the ground that such a sequence
would make Him Ungenerate from Ungenerate. Let him, however, cool his
combative heart, and insist upon the proper expressions, for in
confessing His ‘coming from the Father’ he has banished all
ideas of Ungeneracy as regards the Only-begotten; and there will be
then no danger in pronouncing Him Eternal and yet not Ungenerate. On
the one hand, because the existence of the Son is not marked by any
intervals of time, and the infinitude of His life flows back before the
ages and onward beyond them in an all-pervading tide, He is properly
addressed with the title of Eternal; again, on the other hand, because
the thought of Him as Son in fact and title gives us the thought of the
Father as inalienably joined to it, He thereby stands clear of an
ungenerate existence being imputed to Him, while He is always with a
Father Who always is, as those inspired words of our Master expressed
it, “bound by way of generation to His Father’s
Ungeneracy.” Our account of the Holy Ghost will be the same also;
the difference is only in the place assigned in order. For as the Son
is bound to the Father, and, while deriving existence from Him, is not
substantially after Him, so again the Holy Spirit is in touch with the
Only-begotten, Who is conceived of as before the Spirit’s
subsistence only in the theoretical light of a cause τὸν τῆς
αἰτίας
λόγον. This is much
more probably the meaning, because of before above, than
“on the score of the different kind of causation” (Non omne
quod procedat nascitur, quamvis omne procedat quod nascitur. S.
August.). It is a direct testimony to the ‘Filioque’
belief. “The Spirit comes forth with the Word, not begotten with
Him, but being with and accompanying and proceeding from Him.”
Theodoret. Serm. II..
Extensions in time find no admittance in the Eternal Life; so that,
when we have removed the thought of cause, the Holy Trinity in no
single way exhibits discord with itself; and to It is glory
due.