severed from the Church throughout the world. For in that, when that question was yet
undecided for want of full discussion, though his sentiments differed from those of many
of his colleagues, yet he observed so great moderation, that he would not mutilate the sacred
fellowship of the Church of God by any stain of schism, a greater strength of excellence ap-
peared in him than would have been shown if, without that virtue, he had held views on
every point not only true, but coinciding with their own. Nor should I be acting as he would
wish, if I were to pretend to prefer his talent and his fluency of discourse and copiousness
of learning to the holy Council of all nations, whereat he was assuredly present through the
unity of his spirit, especially as he is now placed in such full light of truth as to see with
perfect certainty what he was here seeking in the spirit of perfect peace. For out of that rich
abundance he smiles at all that here seems eloquence in us, as though it were the first essay
of infancy; there he sees by what rule of piety he acted here, that nothing should be dearer
in the Church to him than unity. There, too, with unspeakable delight he beholds with what
prescient and most merciful providence the Lord, that He might heal our swellings, "chose
the foolish things of the world to confound the wise," 1515 and, in the ordering of the
472
members of His Church, placed all things in such a healthful way, that men should not say
that they were chosen to the help of the gospel for their own talent or learning, of whose
source they yet were ignorant, and so be puffed up with deadly pride. Oh, how Cyprian
rejoices! With how much more perfect calmness does he behold how greatly it conduces
to the health of the human race, that in the writings even of Christian and pious orators
there should be found what merits blame, and in the writings of the fishermen there should
nothing of the sort be found! And so I, being fully assured of this joy of that holy soul,
neither in any way venture to think or say that my writings are free from every kind of error,
nor, in opposing that opinion of his, wherein it seemed to him that those who came from
among heretics were to be received otherwise than either they had been in former days, as
he himself bears witness, or are now received, as is the reasonable custom, confirmed by a
plenary Council of the whole Christian world, do I set against him my own view, but that
of the holy Catholic Church, which he so loved and loves, in which he brought forth such
abundant fruit with tolerance, whose entirety he himself was not, but in whose entirety he
remained; whose root he never left, but, though he already brought forth fruit from its root,
he was purged by the heavenly Husbandman that he should bring forth more fruit;1516 for
whose peace and safety, that the wheat might not be rooted out together with the tares, he
both reproved with the freedom of truth, and endured with the grace of charity, so many
evils on the part of men who were placed in unity with himself.
1515 1 Cor. i. 27.
1516 John xv. 2.
844
Chapter 17