being given to the sentence of the Apostolic See. Not so, according to the Acts; but rather,
by the intervention of a General Council’s authority (the convocation of which, according
to the discipline of those times, was left to the Emperor), the Council itself understood that
all proceedings were of course suspended, and depended on the sentence of the Council.
Wherefore, though the decree of the Pontiff had been promulged and notified, and the ten
days had long been past, Nestorius was held by the Council itself to be a bishop, and called
by the name of most religious bishop, and by that name, too, thrice cited and summoned
to take his seat with the other bishops in the holy Council; for this expression, “to take his
seat,” is distinctly written; and it is added, “in order to answer to what was charged against
him.” For it was their full purpose that he should recognise in whatever way, the Ecumen-
ical Council, as he would then afterwards be, beyond doubt, answerable to it; but he refused
to come, and chose to have his doors besieged with an armed force, that no one might ap-
proach him.
Thereupon, as the Emperor commanded, and the Canons required, the rule of Faith
was set forth, and the Nicene Creed read, as the standard to which all should be referred,
and then the letters of Cyril and Nestorius were examined in order. The letter of Cyril was
first brought before the judgment of the Council. That letter, I mean, concerning the Faith,
to Nestorius, so expressly approved by Pope Celestine, of which he had declared to Cyril,
194
“We see that you hold and maintain all that we hold and maintain”; which, by the decree
against Nestorius, published to all Churches, he had approved, and wishes to be considered
as a canonical monition against Nestorius: that letter, I repeat, was examined, at the propos-
ition of Cyril himself, in these words: “I am persuaded that I have in nothing departed from
the orthodox Faith, or the Nicene Creed; wherefore I beseech your Holiness to set forth
openly whether I have written this correctly, blamelessly, and in accordance with that holy
Council.”
And are there those who say that questions concerning the Faith, once judged by the
Roman Pontiff on his Apostolical authority, are examined in general Councils, in order to
understand their contents, but not to decide on their substance, as being still a matter of
question? Let them hear Cyril, the President of the Council; let them attend to what he
proposes for the inquiry of the Council; and though he were conscious of no error in himself
yet, not to trust himself, he asked for the sentence of the Council in these words “whether
I have written correctly and blamelessly, or not.” This Cyril, the chief of the Council, proposes
for their consideration. Who ever even heard it whispered that, after a final and irreversible
judgment of the Church on a matter of Faith, any such inquiry or question was made? It
was never done, for that would be to doubt about the Faith itself, when declared and dis-
cussed. But this was done after the judgment of Pope Celestine; neither Cyril, nor anyone
else, thought of any other course: that, therefore, was not a final and irreversible judgment.
374
Historical Introduction.