Chapter 12.—17. But the blessed Cyprian shows that it was no new or sudden thing
that he decided, because the practice had already begun under Agrippinus. "Many years,"
he says, "and much time has passed away since, under Agrippinus of honored memory, a
large assembly of bishops determined this point." Accordingly, under Agrippinus, at any
rate, the thing was new. But I cannot understand what Cyprian means by saying, "And
thenceforward to the present day, so many thousand heretics in our provinces, having been
converted to our Church, showed no hesitation or dislike, but rather with full consent of
reason and will, have embraced the opportunity of the grace of the laver of life and the
baptism unto salvation,"1285 unless indeed he says, "thenceforward to the present day," be-
cause from the time when they were baptized in the Church, in accordance with the Council
of Agrippinus, no question of excommunication had arisen in the case of any of the rebap-
tized. Yet if the custom of baptizing those who came over from heretics remained in force
from the time of Agrippinus to that of Cyprian, why should new Councils have been held
by Cyprian on this point? Why does he say to this same Jubaianus that he is not doing
anything new or sudden, but only what had been established by Agrippinus? For why should
Jubaianus be disturbed by the question of novelty, so as to require to be satisfied by the au-
thority of Agrippinus, if this was the continuous practice of the Church from Agrippinus
till Cyprian? Why, lastly, did so many of his colleagues urge that reason and truth must be
preferred to custom, instead of saying that those who wished to act otherwise were acting
contrary to truth and custom alike?
1285 Cypr. Ep. lxxiii. 3.
Chapter 12
766
Chapter 12