This
Minucius Fundanus is the same person that is addressed by Pliny,
Ep. I. 9 (see Mommsen’s note in Keil’s ed. of
Pliny’s epistles, p. 419). He is mentioned also by Melito
(Eusebius, IV. 26) as proconsul of Asia, and it is there said that
Hadrian wrote to him concerning the Christians. The authenticity of
this rescript is a disputed point. Keim (Theol. Jahrbücher,
1856, p. 387 sqq.) was the first to dispute its genuineness. He has
been followed by many scholars, especially Overbeck, who gives a very
keen discussion of the various edicts of the early emperors relating to
the Christians in his Studien zur Gesch. der alten Kirche, I. p.
93 sqq. The genuineness of the edict, however, has been defended
against Keim’s attack by Wieseler, Renan, Lightfoot, and others.
The whole question hinges upon the interpretation of the rescript.
According to Gieseler, Neander, and some others, it is aimed only
against tumultuous proceedings, and, far from departing from the
principle laid down by Trajan, is an attempt to return to that
principle and to substitute orderly judicial processes for popular
attacks. If this be the sense of the edict, there is no reason to doubt
its genuineness, but the next to the last sentence certainly cannot be
interpreted in that way: “if any one therefore brings an
accusation, and shows that they have done something contrary to the
laws (τι
παρὰ τοὺς
νόμους)
determine thus according to the heinousness of the crime”
(κατὰ
τὴν δύναμιν
τοῦ
ἁμαρτήματος). These last words are very significant. They certainly
imply various crimes of which the prisoners are supposed to be accused.
According to the heinousness of these crimes the punishment is to be
regulated. In other words, the trial of the Christians was to be for
the purpose of ascertaining whether they were guilty of moral or
political crimes, not whether they merely professed Christianity; that
is, the profession of Christianity, according to this rescript, is not
treated as a crime in and of itself. If the edict then be genuine,
Hadrian reversed completely Trajan’s principle of procedure which
was to punish the profession of Christianity in and of itself as a
crime. But in the time of Antoninus Pius and Marcus Aurelius the
rescript of Trajan is seen still to be in full force. For this and
other reasons presented by Keim and Overbeck, I am constrained to class
this edict with those of Antoninus Pius and Marcus Aurelius as a
forgery. It can hardly have been composed while Hadrian was still
alive, but must have been forged before Justin wrote his Apology, for
he gives it as a genuine edict, i.e. it must belong to the early part
of the reign of Antoninus Pius.
The illusion under which
the early Christian writers labored in regard to the relations of the
emperors to Christianity is very remarkable. Both Melito and Tertullian
state that no emperor had persecuted the Christians except Nero and
Domitian. Christian writers throughout the second century talk in fact
as if the mode of treatment which they were receiving was something new
and strange, and in opposition to the better treatment which previous
emperors had accorded the Christians. In doing this, they ignore
entirely the actual edicts of the emperors, all of which are now lost
and notice only forged edicts which are favorable to the Christians;
when and by whom they were forged we do not know. Thus Tertullian, in
addressing Septimius Severus, speaks of the favors which his
predecessors had granted the Christians and contrasts their conduct
with his; Melito addresses Marcus Aurelius in the same way, and so
Justin addresses Antoninus Pius. This method probably arose from a
misunderstanding of the original edict of Trajan (cf. Bk. III. chap.
33, note 6), which they all considered favorable, and therefore
presupposed a friendly attitude on the part of the emperors toward the
Christians, which, not finding in their own age, they naturally
transferred to a previous age. This led gradually to the
idea—which Lactantius first gives precise expression
to—that only the bad emperors persecuted Christianity, while the
good ones were favorable to it. But after the empire became Christian,
the belief became common that all the heathen emperors had been
persecutors, the good as well as the bad;—all the Christian
emperors were placed upon one level, and all the heathen on another,
the latter being looked upon, like Nero and Domitian, as wicked
tyrants. Compare Overbeck, l.c.