But one
subject of controversy there was, which especially troubled him; viz.,
that of “the three Chapters” (tria capitula),
consequent upon the condemnation of the documents so-called, and of
their deceased authors, at the instance of the Emperor Justinian, by
the fifth General Council (a.d. 553).
This condemnation had been in fact forced upon the Church by the
Emperor in the said Council under his presidency at Constantinople, in
spite of the protest of the great majority of the Western bishops, and
of the then bishop of Rome, Vigilius. The grounds of objection to
the condemnation were, that it was held to contravene the Council of
Chalcedon, at which two of the writers whom it was proposed to
condemn-—Theodoret and Ibas—had been expressly acquitted of
heresy; that to anathematize the dead, whatever their opinions might
have been, was wrong; and further, that the condemnation was intended
to conciliate the Monophysites, to whom the writers in question had
been peculiarly obnoxious, and was in fact a concession to their
heresy. Nor can it be doubted that a design to conciliate the
Monophysite party, still strong and resolute in spite of its
condemnation at Chalcedon, had been a main motive with Justinian in
forcing a decree against the Three Chapters on the Church.
Vigilius, however, had afterwards yielded to pressure, and assented,
however inconsistently, to the condemnation of the Chapters; as did his
successors in the See of Rome, including Gregory. Consequently
several Churches of the West had renounced communion with Rome; and the
schism thus arising—as in Liguria, which was under the
metropolitan of Milan, and still more decidedly in Istria and Venetia
under the metropolis of Aquileia—continued throughout the reign
of Gregory. He in vain endeavoured, either by remonstrance or by
trying to enlist the emperor’s aid, to bring back the Istrian
bishops to conformity; and it must have been distressing to him, that
even the Lombard queen, Theodelinda, who was so orthodox a Catholic,
and whom he esteemed so highly, and corresponded with so
cordially, herself could not be induced to accept the fifth Council, so
far as the condemnation of the Three Chapters was concerned. In
his last extant letter to her, written in the year of his death, he
regrets that severe illness prevented him from replying to certain
arguments on the subject by an abbot, Secundus, which she had sent for
his consideration, but transmits to her a copy of the Acts of the
fifth council, and again repeats his constant protest that his
acceptance of that Council by no means implied any disparagement of the
previous councils, or of the Tome of pope Leo (Lib. XIV.,
Ep. 12). Further, the schism of the Donatists still lingered in
the African provinces, though no longer powerful, and though a series
of Imperial edicts had been issued for their suppression. We find
Gregory, in many letters, urging measures against them, and more rigid
enforcement of the penal laws.