541
clear you of responsibility, that all the evil that is done by men of your party is done in op-
position to your wishes, why then have you separated yourselves? For if your reason for
not separating from the unrighteous among the party of Donatus is that each man bears his
own burden, why have you separated yourselves from those throughout the world whom
you think, or profess to think, to be unrighteous? Is it that you might all share equally in
bearing the burden of schism?
46. And when we ask of you which of your party you can prove to have been slain by
us, I indeed can remember no law issued by the emperors to the effect that you should be
put to death. Those indeed whose deaths you quote most frequently to bring us into odium,
Marculus and Donatus, present a great question,—whether they threw themselves down a
precipice, as your teaching does not hesitate to encourage by examples of daily occurrence,
or whether they were thrown down by the true command of some authority. For if it is a
thing incredible that the leaders of the Circumcelliones should have wrought upon themselves
a death in accordance with their custom, how much more incredible it is that the Roman
authorities should have been able to condemn them to a punishment at variance with cus-
tom! Accordingly, in considering this matter, which you think excessive in its hatefulness,
supposing what you say is true, what is there in it which bears upon the Lord’s wheat? Let
the chaff which flew away outside accuse the chaff which yet remained within for it is not
possible that it should all be separated till the winnowing at the last day. But if what you
say is false, what wonder is it if, when the chaff is carried away as it were by a light blast of
dissension, it even attacks the wheat of the Lord with false accusations? Wherefore, on the
consideration of all such odious accusations, the wheat of Christ, which is ordered to grow
together with the tares throughout the field, that is, throughout the whole world, makes this
answer to you with a free and fearless voice: If you cannot prove what you say, it has no
application to any one; and if you prove it, it yet does not apply to me. The result of which
is, that whosoever has separated himself from the unity of the wheat on account of the of-
fenses chargeable against the tares, or against the chaff, is unable to defend himself from
the charge of murder which is involved in the mere offense of dissension and schism, as the
Scripture says, "Whoso hateth his brother is a murderer."2039
2039 1 John iii. 15.
1040
Chapter 20