seem to be indicated that these common and familiar natural phenomena were actually
produced.
11. If, however, more subtle reasoning or more thorough investigation of the matter
result in demonstrating that that which is naturally destitute of motion both in time and in
space [i.e. matter] cannot be moved otherwise than through the intermediate agency of that
which is capable of motion only in time, not in space [i.e. spirit], it will follow from this that
all those things must have been done by the instrumentality of a living creature, as things
are done by angels, on which subject a more elaborate discussion would be tedious, and is
not necessary. To this it must be added, that there are visions which appear to the spirit as
plainly as to the senses of the body, not only in sleep or delirium, but also to persons of
sound mind in their waking hours,—visions which are due not to the deceitfulness of devils
mocking men, but to some spiritual revelation accomplished by means of immaterial forms
resembling bodies, and which cannot by any means be distinguished from real objects, unless
they are by divine assistance more fully revealed and discriminated by the mind’s intelligence,
which is done sometimes (but with difficulty) at the time, but for the most part after they
have disappeared. This being the case in regard to these visions which, whether their nature
be really material, or material only in appearance but really spiritual, seem to manifest
themselves to our spirit as if they were perceived by the bodily senses, we ought not, when
these things are recorded in sacred Scripture, to conclude hastily to which of these two
classes they are to be referred, or whether, if they belong to the former, they are produced
by the intermediate agency of a spirit; while, at the same time, as to the invisible and immut-
able nature of the Creator, that is, of the supreme and ineffable Trinity, we either simply,
without any doubt, believe, or, in addition to this, with some degree of intellectual appre-
hension, understand that it is wholly removed and separated both from the senses of fleshly
mortals, and from all susceptibility of being changed either for the worse or for the better,
or to anything whatever of a variable nature.
Chap. IV.
12. These things I send you in reference to two of your questions,—the one concerning
the Trinity, and the other concerning the dove in which the Holy Spirit, not in His own
nature, but in a symbolical form, was manifested, as also the Son of God, not in His eternal
Sonship (of which the Father said: “Before the morning star I have begotten Thee”2802), but
in that human nature which He assumed from the Virgin’s womb, was crucified by the Jews:
observe that to you who are at leisure I have been able, notwithstanding immense pressure
of business, to write so much. I have not, however, deemed it necessary to discuss everything
2802 Ps. cx. 3, LXX.
1150
To Evodius