305
the proverb “in the multitude of words there wanteth not sin.”3206 Put boldly before him
the doctrines of orthodoxy, in order that his amendment may be published abroad, and his
repentance made known to his brethren.
3. It is also desirable that I should remind your reverence about the followers of Mar-
cellus, in order that you may decide nothing in their case rashly or inconsiderately. On ac-
count of his impious doctrines he has gone out from the Church.3207 It is therefore necessary
that his followers should only be received into communion on condition that they anathem-
atize that heresy, in order that those who are united to me through you may be accepted by
all the brethren. And now most men are moved to no small grief on hearing that you have
both received them and admitted them to ecclesiastical communion on their coming to
your excellency. Nevertheless you ought to have known that by God’s grace you do not
stand alone in the East, but have many in communion with you, who vindicate the orthodoxy
of the Fathers, and who put forth the pious doctrine of the Faith at Nicæa. The Westerns
also all agree with you and with me, whose exposition of the Faith I have received and keep
with me, assenting to their sound doctrine. You ought, then, to have satisfied all who are
in agreement with you, that the action which is being taken may be ratified by the general
consent, and that peace may not be broken by the acceptance of some while others are kept
apart. Thus you ought to have at the same time seriously and gently taken counsel about
matters which are of importance to all the Churches throughout the world. Praise is not
due to him who hastily determines any point, but rather to him who rules every detail firmly
3206 Prov. x. 19.
3207 Here the Ben. note is Mirum id videtur ac prima specie vix credibile, Marcellum ob impios errores ex ec-
clesia exiisee. Nam S. Athanasius suspectum illum quidem, sed tamen purgatum habuit, teste Epiphanio, Hæres.
lxxii. lxxii. p. 837. Hinc illius discipuli communicatorias beatissimi papæ Athanasii litteras ostenderunt confess-
oribus Ægyptiis, ibid. p. 843. Testatur idem Epiphanius varia esse Catholicorum de Marcello judicia, aliis eum
accusantibus, aliis defendentibus, p. 834. Paulinus ejus discipulos sine discrimine recipiebat, ut in superiore epistola
vidimus. Ipse Basilius in epist. 69 queritur quod eum Ecclesia Romana in communionem ab initio suscepisset.
Quomodo ergo exiise dicitur ex Ecclesia qui tot habuit communicatores? Sed tamen S. Basilii testimonium cum
sua sponte magni est momenti (non enim ut in dijudicandis Marcelli scriptis, ita in ejusmodi facto proclive fuit
errare), tum etiam hoc argumento confirmatur quod Athanasius extremis vitæ suæ annis Marcellum a communione
sua removerit. Neque enim, si semper cum eo communicasset Athanasius, opus habuissent illius discipuli confessione
fidei ad impetrandam confessorum Ægyptiorum communionem: nec Petrus Athanasii successor canones violatos,
concessa illis communione, quereretur, ut videmus in epistola sequenti, si Ægyptum inter ac Marcellum ejusque
clerum et plebem non fuisset rupta communio. Videtur ergo Marcellus sub finem vitæ aliquid peccasse, quod
Athanasium ab ejus communione discedere cogeret: et cum jamdudum a tota fere oriente damnatus esset, amissa
Athanasii communione, quæ unicum fere illius refugium erat, desertus ab omnibus videri debuit, nec ei nova ig-
nominia notato prodesse poterat concessa olim a Romana Ecclesia communio.
830
To Eulogius, Alexander, and Harpocration, bishops of Egypt, in exile.