3. The “Book of Canons” by no means
represents an authorized textus receptus, and after its
publication, the Holy Synod itself not unfrequently introduced the
Canons as given in the Slavonic edition of the “Kormchaja
Kniga” into its edicts, and moreover recommended the Athenian
Edition of the “Syntagma” for all the
ecclesiastico-educational establishments. This opened the way for
a new work, which, with the permission of the supreme ecclesiastical
authority, was undertaken by the Moscow “Society of Amateurs of
Spiritual Enlightenment.” The announcement of this was made
in No. 3 of the “Moscow Diocesan Church Gazette” of the
year 1875, whilst in the same year in the January number of the Moscow
Journal, “Lectures delivered in the Society of Amateurs of
Spiritual Enlightenment,” the “programe” of the
edition itself was printed (pages 79–90 in the section devoted to
bibliography). In criticism of it the Professor of Canonical Law
in the University of Novorossiisk, Alexis Stepanovich Pavloff (who died
on August 16, 1898, as Professor of the University of Moscow) wrote
“Notes on the programme of an edition, in a Russian translation
of the Canons of the Church with Commentaries” in the sixteenth
volume of “Memoirs of the Imperial University of
Novorossiisk” (Odessa, 1875), pages 1–17 of the Appendix
(and in a separate pamphlet), which was afterwards reprinted with
certain additions in the Moscow Journal, “Orthodox Review,”
of April, 1876 (pages 730–746), under the title: “A
new translation of the Commentaries upon the canons of the
church.” To these criticisms the Professor of Ecclesiastical Law in the Moscow Ecclesiastical
Academy, Alexander Theodorovich Lavroff, wrote a reply in
“Lectures delivered in the Society of Amateurs of Spiritual
Enlightenment” (for the year 1877, part 2, pages 158–194),
entitled “A printed letter to Alexis Stepanovich
Pavloff.” Thus the plan of the edition gradually took
shape. It was first printed in the Appendices to the Journal
“Lectures in the Society, etc.,” and subsequently was
published separately in octavo in the following parts (A) I.
“The Canons of the Holy Apostles with Commentaries” in two
editions—Moscow, 1876, (from “Lectures,” 1875, pages
1–163) 4 + 12 + 175 pages, and ibid., 1887, 5–12 + 163
pages; II. “Canons of the Holy Ecumenical Councils with
Commentaries” (from “Lectures” 1875, pages
165–325; 1876, pages 329–680; 1877, pages 891–900),
in two parts: 1st “The Canons of the Councils
I.–IV.,” Moscow, 1877, 260 pages; 2d. “The Canons of
Councils V.–VII.,” ibid., 736 pages; (B) “The Canons
of the Holy Local Councils with Commentaries,” also in two parts
(from “Lectures” 1877, pages 900–1066; 1878, pages
1067–1306; 1879, pages 1307–1410): the 1st (The
Canons of the Councils of Ancyra, Neocæsarea, Gangra, Antioch,
Laodicea, and Sardica) Moscow, 1880, 359 pages; the 2d (The Canons of
the Councils of Carthage [with the letters to Pope Boniface and to Pope
Celestine], Constantinople, the First-and-Second, and that in the
Temple of the Wisdom of the Word of God) ibid., 1881, 876 pages; (C)
“The Canons of the Holy Fathers with Commentaries,” ibid.,
1884, 626 pages. Together with these is a separate “Index
of subjects contained in the edition of the Canons of the Apostles,
Councils and Holy Fathers with Commentaries,” Moscow, 1888, 58
pages in octavo. The Greek text of the canons follows the
edition Σύνταγμα
τῶν θείων καὶ
ὶερῶν
κανόνων…ὑπὸ Γ. Α.
Ράλλη καὶ Μ.
Πότλη,
Αθήνησιν
1852–1854, and alongside of it is placed a literal Slavonic
translation, after which follows a Russian translation of the
Commentaries of the Byzantine Canonists (Zonaras, Aristenus, Balsamon),
and the text and commentaries of the Slavonic “Kormchaja;”
all this is accompanied by introductions and explanations of all sorts
(historical, philological, etc.). This edition is rightly
considered by specialists to be of very great value from a scientific
point of view. Professor A. Th. Lavroff (who became a monk under
the name Alexis, and died Archbishop of Lithuania and Vilna) was its
chief editor and had most to do with it, but many others took part in
the work, and amongst these Professor A. S. Pavloff.