The council (a) had
testified, by its horrified and spontaneous rejection of it, that
Arianism was a novelty subversive of the Christian faith as they had
received it from their fathers. They had (b) banished it from the
Church by an inexorable test, which even the leading supporters of
Arius had been induced to subscribe. In the years immediately
following, we find (c) a large majority of the Eastern bishops,
especially of Syria and Asia Minor, the very regions whence the
numerical strength of the council was drawn, in full reaction against
the council; first against the leaders of the victorious party,
eventually and for nearly a whole generation against the symbol itself;
the final victory of the latter in the East being the result of the
slow growth of conviction, a growth independent of the authority of the
council which it eventually was led to recognise. To understand this
paradox of history, which determines the whole story of the life of
Athanasius as bishop, it is necessary to estimate at some length the
theological and ecclesiastical situation at the close of the council:
this will best be done by examining each point in turn (a) the novelty
of Arianism, (b) the ὁμοούσιον as a
theological formula, (c) the materials for reaction.