428 JEROME.
and you were therefore unable to cheat your
hearers, you preferred to maintain unbroken
silence rather than openly confess what had
been covered in obscurity ?
7. The questions relate to the passages in
the 'Ilepi Apx&v. The first is this, " for as it is unfitting to say that the Son can see the
Father, so neither is it meet to think that the
Holy Spirit can see the Son." The second point is the statement that souls are tied up
in the body as in a prison ; and that before
man was made in Paradise they dwelt amongst
rational creatures in the heavens. Where-
fore, afterwards to console itself, the soul
says in the Psalms,2 " Before I was humbled,
I went wrong" ; and l< Return, my soul, to
thy rest" ; and " Lead my soul out of pris-
on " ; and similarly elsewhere. Thirdly, he says that both the devil and demons will some
time or other repent, and ultimately reign with
the saints. Fourthly, he interprets the coats
of skin, with which Adam and Eve were
clothed after their fall and ejection from
Paradise, to be human bodies, and we are to
suppose of course that previously, in Paradise,
they had neither flesh, sinews, nor bones.
Fifthly, he most openly denies the resurrec-
tion of the flesh and the bodily structure, and
the distinction of senses, both in his explana-
tion of the first Psalm, and in many other of
his treatises. Sixthly, he so allegorises Para-
dise as to destroy historical truth, under-
standing angels instead of trees, heavenly vir-
tues instead of rivers, and he overthrows all
that is contained in the history of Paradise by
his figurative interpretation. Seventhly, he
thinks that the waters which are said in Scrip-
ture to be above the heavens are holy and
supernal essences, while those which are
above the earth and beneath the earth are,
on the contrary, demoniacal essences. The
eighth is Origen's cavil that the image and like- ness of God, in which man was created, was
lost, and was no -longer in man after he was expelled from Paradise.
8. These are the arrows with which you
are pierced ; these the weapons with which
throughout the whole letter you are wounded;
or I should rather say Epiphanius throws him-
self as a suppliant at your knees, and casts
his hoary locks beneath your feet, and, for a
time laying aside his episcopal dignity, prays for your salvation in words such as these :
"Grant to me and to yourself the favour of your salvation ; save yourself, as it is written,
from this crooked generation,5 and forsake the heresy of Origen, and all heresies, dearly
beloved." And lower down, " In the defence
1 Origen's great speculative work "On First Principles." » Ps. cxix. 67. 3 Ps. cxvi. 7. * Ps. cxlii. 7. 6 Acts u. 40.
of heresy you kindle hatred against me, and
destroy that love which I had towards you ;
insomuch that you would make us even repent
of holding communion with you who so reso-
lutely defend the errors and doctrines of
Origen." Tell me, prince of arguers, to which, out of the eight sections, you have
replied. For the present, I say nothing of
the rest. Take the first blasphemy- — that the
Son cannot see the Father, nor the Holy
Spirit the Son. By what weapons of yours
has it been pierced ? The answer we get is,
" We believe that the Holy and Adorable Trinity are of the same substance ; that they
are co-eternal, and of the same glory and
Godhead, and we anathematize those who say
that there is any greatness, smallness, ine-
quality, or aught that is visible in the God-
head of the Trinity. But as we say the
Father is incorporeal, invisible, and eternal ;
so we say the Son and Holy Spirit are incor-
poreal, invisible, and eternal." If you did not say this, you would not hold to the Church. I do not ask whether there was not
a time when you refused to say this. I will
not discuss the question, whether you were
fond of those who preached such doctrines;
on whose side you were when, for expressing
those sentiments, they underwent banish- ment ; or who the man was that, when the
presbyter Theo preached in the Church that
the Holy Spirit is God, closed his ears,
and excitedly rushed out of doors that he
might not so much as hear the impiety. I
recognize a man, as one may say, as one of
the faithful, even though his repentance
comes late. M'hatf unhappy man Praetexta- tus, who died after he had been chosen con-
sul, a profane person and an idolater, was
wont in sport to say to blessed Pope Damas-
cus, " Make me bishop of Rome, and I will at
once be a Christian." Why do you, with many words and intricate periods, take the trouble
to show me that you are not an Arian ? Either
deny that the accused said what is imputed
to him, or, if he did give utterance to such
sentiments, condemn him for so speaking.
You have still to learn how intense is the
zeal of the orthodox. Listen to the Apostle :
""•If I or an angel from heaven bring you
another gospel than that we have declared, let ' him be anathema." You would extenuate the fault and hide the name of the guilty party :
as though everything were right and no one
were accused of blasphemy, you frame, in
artificial language, an uncalled-for profession
of your faith. Speak out at once, and let
1 Vettius Agorius Praetextatus, one of the most virtuous of the heathen. Jerome writes of him to Marcella (Letter XXI11. 2):
" I wish you to know that the consul designate is now in Tar-
tarus."
» Gal. i. 8.