publication of these works now, in order that they may be defended in my own lifetime by
myself, when, perhaps, they may begin to be assailed in some particulars, either through
the cavilling of enemies or the misapprehensions of friends. You say this doubtless because
you think there is nothing in them which might with justice be censured, otherwise you
would not exhort me to publish the books, but rather to revise them more carefully. But I
fix my eye rather on those who are true judges, sternly impartial, between whom and myself
I wish, in the first place, to make sure of my ground, so that the only faults coming to be
censured by them may be those which it was impossible for me to observe, though using
the most diligent scrutiny.
5. Notwithstanding what I have just said, I am prepared to defend the sentence in the
third book of my treatise on Free Will, in which, discoursing on the rational substance, I
have expressed my opinion in these words: “The soul, appointed to occupy a body inferior
in nature to itself after the entrance of sin, governs its own body, not absolutely according
to its free will, but only in so far as the laws of the universe permit.” I bespeak the particular
attention of those who think that I have here fixed and defined, as ascertained concerning
the human soul, either that it comes by propagation from the parents, or that it has, through
sins committed in a higher celestial life, incurred the penalty of being shut up in a corruptible
body. Let them, I say, observe that the words in question have been so carefully weighed by
me, that while they hold fast what I regard as certain, namely, that after the sin of the first
man, all other men have been born and continue to be born in that sinful flesh, for the
healing of which “the likeness of sinful flesh”2571 came in the person of the Lord, they are
also so chosen as not to pronounce upon any one of those four opinions which I have in
the sequel expounded and distinguished—not attempting to establish any one of them as
preferable to the others, but disposing in the meantime of the matter under discussion, and
reserving the consideration of these opinions, so that whichever of them may be true, praise
should unhesitatingly be given to God.
6. For whether all souls are derived by propagation from the first, or are in the case of
each individual specially created, or being created apart from the body are sent into it, or
492
introduce themselves into it of their own accord, without doubt this creature endowed with
reason, namely, the human soul—appointed to occupy an inferior, that is, an earthly
body—after the entrance of sin, does not govern its own body absolutely according to its
free will.2572 For I did not say, “after his sin,” or “after he sinned,” but after the entrance of
sin, that whatever might afterwards, if possible, be determined by reason as to the question
whether the sin was his own or the sin of the first parent of mankind, it might be perceived
2571 Rom. viii. 3.
2572 The text here obscure, we have followed the Mss., which omit the words, “interim quod constat peccatum
primi hominis.”
1054
To Marcellinus