Sittl, (Jahresber; u. class.
Alterthumsw. 1888. 2 p. 243) says that the edition “without the
preface which contains a collation of Codex Corbeiensis would be
worthless.” This is a little strong, for the readings he gives
from Vaticanus have a decided value in default of other sources for its
readings and his strict following of this often produces a correct
reading against Vallarsi who was naturally inclined to follow
Veronensis and Corbeiensis both of which were probably a good deal
manipulated after they left the hand of Gennadius. The collation of
Corbeiensis besides excluding Gennadius is not over exact and some of
the most effaced pages seem to have been given up entirely by the
collator.