which was a new idea to them. It would take too long to show the consistency of the two
things here. But when the Manichæans condemn without exception the precept, Thou shall
hate thine enemy, they may easily be met with the question whether their god loves the race
of darkness. Or, if we should love our enemies now, because they have a part of good, should
we not also hate them as having a part of evil? So even in this way it would appear that there
is no opposition between the saying of ancient times, Thou shall hate thine enemy, and that
of the Gospel, Love your enemies. For every wicked man should be hated as far as he is
wicked; while he should be loved as a man. The vice which we rightly hate in him is to be
condemned, that by its removal the human nature which we rightly love in him may be
amended. This is precisely the principle we maintain, that we should hate our enemy for
what is evil in him, that is, for his wickedness; while we also love our enemy for that which
is good in him, that is, for his nature as a social and rational being. The difference between
us and the Manichæans is, that we prove the man to be wicked, not by nature, either his
own or any other, but by his own will; whereas they think that a man is evil on account of
the nature of the race of darkness, which, according to them, was an object of dread to God
when he existed entire, and by which also he was partly conquered, so that he cannot be
entirely set free. The intention of the Lord, then, is to correct those who, from knowing
without understanding what was said by them of old time, Thou shalt hate thine enemy,
hated their fellow-men instead of only hating their wickedness; and for this purpose He
says, Love your enemies. Instead of destroying what is written about hatred of enemies in
the law, of which He said, "I am come not to destroy the law, but to fulfill it," He would have
us learn, from the duty of loving our enemies, how it is possible in the case of one and the
same person, both to hate him for his sin, and to love him for his nature. It is too much to
expect our perverse opponents to understand this. But we can silence them, by showing
that by their irrational objection they condemn their own god, of whom they cannot say
that he loves the race of darkness; so that in enjoining on every one to love his enemy, they
cannot quote his example. There would appear to be more love of their enemy in the race
of darkness than in the god of the Manichæans. The story is, that the race of darkness
coveted the domain of light bordering on their territory, and, from a desire to possess it,
formed the plan of invading it. Nor is there any sin in desiring true goodness and blessed-
ness. For the Lord says, "The kingdom of heaven suffereth violence, and the violent take it
by force."706 This fabulous race of darkness, then, wished to take by force the good they
desired, for its beautiful and attractive appearance. But God, instead of returning the love
of those who wished to possess Him, hated it so as to endeavor to annihilate them. If,
therefore, the evil love the good in the desire to possess it, while the good hate the evil in
fear of being defiled, I ask the Manichæans, which of these obeys the precept of the Lord,
706 Matt. xi. 12.
424
Faustus is willing to admit that Christ may have said that He came not to…