Chapter 13.—How Faulty Interpretations Can Be Emended.
19. But since we do not clearly see what the actual thought is which the several translators
endeavor to express, each according to his own ability and judgment, unless we examine it
in the language which they translate; and since the translator, if he be not a very learned
man, often departs from the meaning of his author, we must either endeavor to get a
knowledge of those languages from which the Scriptures are translated into Latin, or we
must get hold of the translations of those who keep rather close to the letter of the original,
not because these are sufficient, but because we may use them to correct the freedom or the
error of others, who in their translations have chosen to follow the sense quite as much as
the words. For not only single words, but often whole phrases are translated, which could
not be translated at all into the Latin idiom by any one who wished to hold by the usage of
the ancients who spoke Latin. And though these sometimes do not interfere with the un-
derstanding of the passage, yet they are offensive to those who feel greater delight in things
when even the signs of those things are kept in their own purity. For what is called a solecism
is nothing else than the putting of words together according to a different rule from that
which those of our predecessors who spoke with any authority followed. For whether we
say inter homines (among men) or inter hominibus, is of no consequence to a man who only
wishes to know the facts. And in the same way, what is a barbarism but the pronouncing
of a word in a different way from that in which those who spoke Latin before us pronounced
it? For whether the word ignoscere (to pardon) should be pronounced with the third syllable
long or short, is not a matter of much concern to the man who is beseeching God, in any
way at all that he can get the words out, to pardon his sins. What then is purity of speech,
except the preserving of the custom of language established by the authority of former
speakers?
20. And men are easily offended in a matter of this kind, just in proportion as they are
weak; and they are weak just in proportion as they wish to seem learned, not in the knowledge
of things which tend to edification, but in that of signs, by which it is hard not to be puffed
up,1786 seeing that the knowledge of things even would often set up our neck, if it were not
held down by the yoke of our Master. For how does it prevent our understanding it to have
the following passage thus expressed: “Quæ est terra in quo isti insidunt super eam, si bona
est an nequam; et quæ sunt civitates, in quibus ipsi inhabitant in ipsis?”1787 And I am more
disposed to think that this is simply the idiom of another language than that any deeper
meaning is intended. Again, that phrase, which we cannot now take away from the lips of
1786 Comp. 1 Cor. viii. 1.
1787 “And what the land is that they dwell in, whether it be good or bad; and what cities they be that they
dwell in.”— Num. xiii.19 (A.V.).
How Faulty Interpretations Can Be Emended.
1212
How Faulty Interpretations Can Be Emended.