This very circumstantial account has met with doubters from the
very beginning, commencing with Eusebius himself. There are all sorts
of explanations, from that of an actual miracle to that of pure later
invention. The fact of some, at least supposed, special divine
manifestation at this time can hardly be denied. It is mentioned
vaguely by Paneg. 313, and on the triumphal arch shortly after.
It is reported as a dream by Lactantius about the same time with the
erection of the arch, and alluded to in general, but hardly to be
doubted, terms by Nazarius in 321. Moreover, it is witnessed to by the
fact of the standard of the cross which was made. As to the real nature
of the manifestation, it has been thought to be as recorded by
Constantine, and if so, as perhaps some natural phenomenon of the sun,
or to have been a simple dream, or an hallucination. It is hardly
profitable to discuss the possibilities. The lack of contemporary
evidence to details and the description of Lactantius as a dream is
fatal to any idea of a miraculous image with inscriptions clearly seen
by all. Some cross-like arrangement of the clouds, or a
“parahelion,” or some sort of a suggestion of a cross, may
have been seen by all, but evidently there was no definite, vivid,
clear perception, or it would have been in the mouths of all and
certainly recorded, or at least it would not have been recorded as
something else by Lactantius. It seems probable that the
emperor, thinking intensely, with all the weight of his great problem
resting on his energetic mind, wondering if the Christian God was
perhaps the God who could help, saw in some suggestive shape of the
clouds or of sunlight the form of a cross, and there flashed out in his
mind in intensest reality the vision of the words, so that for the
moment he was living in the intensest reality of such a vision. His
mind had just that intense activity to which such a thing is possible
or actual. It is like Goethe’s famous meeting of his own self. It
is that genius power for the realistic representation of ideal things.
This is not the same exactly as “hallucination,” or even
“imagination.” The hallucination probably came later when
Constantine gradually represented to himself and finally to Eusebius
the vivid idea with its slight ground, as an objective reality,—a
common phenomenon. When the emperor went to sleep, his brain molecules
vibrating to the forms of his late intense thought, he inevitably
dreamed, and dreaming naturally confirmed his thought. This does not
say that the suggestive form seen, or the idea itself, and the
direction of the dream itself, were not providential and the work of
the Holy Spirit, for they were, and were special in character, and so
miraculous (or why do ideas come?); but it is to be feared that
Constantine’s own spirit or something else furnished some of the
later details. There is a slight difference of authority as to when and
where the vision took place. The panegyrist seems to make it before
leaving Gaul, and Malalas is inaccurate as usual in having it happen in
a war against the barbarians. For farther discussion of the subject see
monographs under Literature in the Prolegomena, especially under
the names: Baring, Du
Voisin, Fabricius,
Girault, Heumann,
Jacutius Mamachi,
Molinet, St. Victor, Suhr, Toderini, Weidener, Wernsdorf, Woltereck. The most
concise, clear, and admirable supporter of the account of Eusebius, or
rather Constantine, as it stands, is Newman, Miracles (Lond.
1875), 271–286.