TO PAMMACHIUS AGAINST JOHN OF JERUSALEM. 427
ing. make a thousand clerics in an hour.
But you have to answer Epiphanius, our
father in God, who, in the letters which he
sent, openly calls you a heretic. Certainly
you are not his superior in respect of years,
of learning, of his exemplary life, or of the
judgment of the whole world. If it is a
question of age, you are a young man writ- ing to an old one. If it is one of knowledge,
you are a person not so very accomplished
writing to a learned man, although your
partisans maintain that you are a more fin-
ished speaker than Demosthenes, more sharp- witted than Chrysippus, wiser than Plato,
and perhaps have persuaded you that they
are right. As regards his life and devotion
to the faith, I will say no more, that I may
not seem to be seeking to wound you. At
the time when the whole East (except our
fathers in God Athanasius and Paulinus) was
overrun by the Arian and Eunomian heresies ;
when you did not hold communion with the
Westerns ; then, in the very worst of the
exile which made them confessors, he, though
a simple convent priest, gained the ear of
Eutychius, and afterwards as bishop of
Cyprus was unmolested by Valens. For lie
was always so highly venerated that heretics
on the throne thought it would redound to
their own disgrace if they persecuted such a man. Write therefore to him. Answer
his letter. So let the rest understand your
purpose and judge of your eloquence and
wisdom ; do not keep all your accomplish-
ments to yourself. Why, when you are chal-
lenged, in one quarter, do you turn your arms
towards another? A question is put to you
in Palestine, your answer is given in Egypt.
When some are blear-eyed, you anoint the
eyes of others who are not affected. If you
tell another what is meant to give us satisfac-
tion, such action springs entirely from pride ;
if you tell him what we do not ask for, it is
entirely uncalled for.
5. But you say " the bishop of Alexandria
approved of my letter." What did he ap- prove of ? Your correct utterances against
Arius, Photinus, and Manichaeus. For who,
at this time of day, accuses you of being an
Arian ? Who now fastens on you the guilt? of Photinus and Manichzeus ? Those faults were
long ago corrected, those enemies were shattered. You were not so foolish as to
openly defend a heresy which you knew was offensive to the whole Church. You knew
that if you had done this, you must have been
immediately removed, and your heart was
upon the pleasures of your episcopal throne.
You so tuned your expressions as to neither
displease the simple, nor offend your own
incontestably marked by deceit and slipperi-
ness ; what, then, are we to do with the re-
maining five, with regard to which, because
no opportunity was afforded for ambiguity,
supporters. You wrote well, but nothing
to the purpose. How was the bishop of
Alexandria to know of what you were accused,
or what things they were of which a confes- sion was demanded from you ? You ought to
have set forth in detail the charges brought
against you, and then have met them one by
one. There is an old story which tells how a
certain man, who, when he was speaking
fluently, was carried along by a torrent of
words, without touching the question before
the court, and thus drew the wise remark from
the judge, " Excellent ! excellent ! but to
what purpose is all this excellence ? " Quacks have but one lotion for all affections of the
eyes. He who is accused of many things, and
in dissipating the charges passes over some,
confesses all that he omits to 'mention. Did
you not reply to the letter of Epiphanius,
and yourself choose the points for refuta- tion ? No doubt, in replying, you rested on
the axiom, that no man is so brave as to put
the sword to his own throat. Choose which
j alternative you like. You shall have your
choice : you either replied to the letter of
Epiphanius, or you did not. If you did reply,
why did you take no notice of the most impor- tant, and the most numerous, of the charges
brought against you ? If you did not reply,
what becomes of your " Apology," of which you boast amongst the simple, and which you are
scattering broadcast amongst those who do not understand the matter ?
6. The questions for you to answer were
arranged, as I shall presently show, under
eight heads. You touch only three, and pass
on. As regards the rest, you maintain a mag- nificent silence. If you had with perfect
frankness replied to seven, I should still cling
to the charge which remained ; and what you
said nothing about, that I should hold to be
the truth. But as things are, you have caught
the wolf by the ears ; you can neither hold
fast, nor dare let go. With a sort of careless
security and an air of abstraction, you skim over and touch the surface of three in which
there is nothing or but little of importance.
And your procedure is so dark and close that
you confess more by your silence than you
rebut by your arguments. Every one has the
right forthwith to say to you,1 "If the light that is in thee be darkness, how great is the
darkness." Even in answering three little questions, respecting which you seemed to
say something, you are not clear from sus- picion and from blame, but your replies are
1 Matt. vi. 23.