It is an historical fact that, in 174 a.d., the Roman army in Hungary was relieved from a very
dangerous predicament by the sudden occurrence of a thunder-storm,
which quenched their thirst and frightened the barbarians, and thus
gave the Romans the victory. By heathen writers this event (quite
naturally considered miraculous) was held to have taken place in answer
to prayer, but by no means in answer to the prayers of the Christians.
Dion Cassius (LXXI. 8) ascribes the supposed miracle to the
conjurations of the Egyptian magician Arnuphis; Capitolinus (Vita
Marc. Aurelii, chap. 24, and Vita Heliogabali, chap. 9), to
the prayer of Marcus Aurelius. The emperor himself expresses his view
upon a coin which represents Jupiter as hurling lightning against the
barbarians (see Eckhel. Numism. III. 61).
As early as the time of
Marcus Aurelius himself the Christians ascribed the merit of the
supposed miracle to their own prayers (e.g. Apolinarius, mentioned just
below), and this became the common belief among them (cf. Tertullian,
Apol. chap. 5, quoted just below, and ad Scap. chap. 4,
and the forged edict of Marcus Aurelius, appended to Justin
Martyr’s first Apology). It is probable that the whole legion
prayed for deliverance to their respective deities, and thus quite
naturally each party claimed the victory for its particular gods. That
there were some Christians in the army of Marcus Aurelius there is, of
course, no reason to doubt, but that a legion at that time was wholly
composed of Christians, as Eusebius implies, is
inconceivable.