5. And immediately his flatterers, some from one place, others from another, raised up
their voices in a way that was not for his good, calling him a god, and saying, ‘Be thou mer-
ciful; if up to this time we have feared thee as a man, henceforth we confess that thou art
superior to the nature of mortals.’
6. The king did not rebuke them, nor did he reject their impious flattery. But after a
little, looking up, he saw an angel sitting above his head.340 And this he quickly perceived
340 The passage in Josephus reads: “But as he presently afterward looked up he saw an owl sitting on a certain
rope over his head, and immediately understood that this bird was the messenger of evil tidings, as it had once
been the messenger of good tidings to him.” This conveys an entirely different sense, the owl being omitted in
Eusebius. As a consequence most writers on Eusebius have made the gravest charges against him, accusing him
of a willful perversion of the text of Josephus with the intention of producing a confirmation of the narrative of
the Acts, in which the angel of God is spoken of, but in which no mention is made of an owl. The case certainly
looks serious, but so severe an accusation—an accusation which impeaches the honesty of Eusebius in the most
direct manner—should not be made except upon unanswerable grounds. Eusebius elsewhere shows himself to
be a writer who, though not always critical, is at least honest in the use he makes of his materials. In this case,
therefore, his general conduct ought to be taken into consideration, and he ought to be given the benefit of the
doubt. Lightfoot, who defends his honesty, gives an explanation which appears to me sufficiently satisfactory.
He says: “Doubtless also the omission of the owl in the account of Herod Agrippa’s death was already in some
texts of Josephus. The manner in which Eusebius deals with his very numerous quotations elsewhere, where we
can test his honesty, is a sufficient vindication against this unjust charge.” And in a note he adds: “It is not the
substitution of an angel for an owl, as the case is not uncommonly stated. The result is produced mainly by the
omission of some words in the text of Josephus, which runs thus: ἀνακύψας δ᾽ οὖν μετ᾽ ὀλίγον[τὸν βουβῶνα]
τῆς ἑαυτοῦ κεφαλῆς ὑπὲρ καθεζόμενον εἶδεν[ἐπὶ σχοινίου τινός] ἀγγελόν[τε] τοῦτον εὐθὺς ἐνόησε κακῶν
εἶναι, τὸν καί ποτε τῶν ἀγαθῶν γενόμενον. The words bracketed are omitted, and αἴτιον is added after εἶναι,
so that the sentence runs, εἶδεν ἄγγελον τοῦτον εὐθὺς ἐνόησε κακῶν εἶναι αἴτιον κ.τ.λ. This being so, I do not
feel at all sure that the change (by whomsoever made) was dictated by any disingenuous motive. A scribe unac-
quainted with Latin would stumble over τὸν βουβῶνα, which had a wholly different meaning and seems never
to have been used of an owl in Greek; and he would alter the text in order to extract some sense out of it. In the
previous mention of the bird (Ant. XVIII. 6, 7) Josephus, or his translator, gives it as a Latin name: βουβῶνα δὲ
οἱ ῾Ρωμαῖοι τὸν ὄρνιν τοῦτον καλοῦσι. Möller (quoted by Bright, p. XLV.) calls this ‘the one case’ in which, so
far as he recollects, ‘a sinceritatis via paululum deflexit noster’; and even here the indictment cannot be made
good. The severe strictures against Eusebius, made e.g. by Alford on Acts xii. 21, are altogether unjustifiable”
(Smith and Wace’s Dict. of Christian Biog. II. p. 325). The Greek word βουβών means, according to Liddell and
Scott, (1) the groin, (2) a swelling in the groin. The Latin word Bubo signifies “an owl,” and the word is here
directly transferred by Josephus from the Latin into Greek without any explanation. A scribe unacquainted with
Latin might easily stumble at the word, as Lightfoot suggests. In Ant. XVIII. 6, 7 where the bird is mentioned,
the name is, to be sure, explained; but the alteration at this point was made apparently by a copyist of Eusebius,
not of Josephus, and therefore by one who had probably never seen that explanation. Whiston in his translation
188
Agrippa, who was also called Herod, having persecuted the Apostles, immediately…