He tries, however, to fight
against our words, and says, a little further on (for I will pass over
at present his intermediate remarks, as they have been more or less
fully discussed in my previous arguments), when he charges us with
being “bold in saying or thinking things uncontrivable,”
and calls us “most miserable Oehler’s punctuation here seems to require
correction.,”—he
adds, I say, this:—“For if it is not of the Word Who was in
the beginning and was God that the blessed Peter speaks, but of Him Who
was ‘seen,’ and Who ‘emptied Himself,’ as Basil
says, and if the man Who was ‘seen’ ‘emptied
Himself’ to take ‘the form of a servant,’ and He Who
‘emptied Himself’ to take the form of a servant,’
‘emptied Himself’ to come into being as man, then the man
who was ‘seen’ ‘emptied himself,’ to come into
being as man.” It may be that the judgment of my readers has
immediately detected from the above citation the knavery, and, at the
same time, the folly of the argument he maintains: yet a brief
refutation of what he says shall be subjoined on our side, not
so much to
overthrow his blundering sophism, which indeed is overthrown by itself
for those who have ears to hear, as to avoid the appearance of passing
his allegation by without discussion, under the pretence of contempt
for the worthlessness of his argument. Let us accordingly look at the
point in this way. What are the Apostle’s words? “Be it
known,” he says, “that God made Him Lord and Christ Acts ii. 36..” Then, as though some one had asked
him on whom such a grace was bestowed, he points as it were with his
finger to the subject, saying, “this Jesus, Whom ye
crucified.” What does Basil say upon this? That the demonstrative
word declares that that person was made Christ, Who had been
crucified by the hearers;—for he says, “ye
crucified,” and it was likely that those who had demanded the
murder that was done upon Him were hearers of the speech; for the time
from the crucifixion to the discourse of Peter was not long. What,
then, does Eunomius advance in answer to this? “If it is not of
the Word Who was in the beginning and was God that the blessed Peter
speaks, but of Him Who was ‘seen,’ and Who ‘emptied
Himself,’ as Basil says, and if the man who was
‘seen’ ‘emptied himself’ to take ‘the
form of a servant’”—Hold! who says this, that the man
who was seen emptied himself again to take the form of a servant? or
who maintains that the suffering of the Cross took place before the
manifestation in the flesh? The Cross did not precede the body, nor the
body “the form of the servant.” But God is manifested in
the flesh, while the flesh that displayed God in itself, after having
by itself fulfilled the great mystery of the Death, is transformed by
commixture to that which is exalted and Divine, becoming Christ and
Lord, being transferred and changed to that which He was, Who
manifested Himself in that flesh. But if we should say this, our
champion of the truth maintains once more that we say that He Who was
shown upon the Cross “emptied Himself” to become another
man, putting his sophism together as follows in its
wording:—“If,” quoth he, “the man who was
‘seen’ ‘emptied himself’ to take the
‘form of a servant,’ and He Who ‘emptied
Himself’ to take the ‘form of a servant,’
‘emptied Himself’ to come into being as man, then the man
who was ‘seen’ ‘emptied himself’ to come into
being as man.”