INTRODUCTORY NOTICE. Xlll
affirmed, no man could be justified in believing it without an
ocular inspection of this earlier first edition — an edition,
however, which as yet is only a phantom of the brain, no
trace of its actual existence having ever been discovered.
Besides, it is of importance to observe, that in the above
passage quoted from the preface to the Psalms, Calvin, to
prove that personal fame could not have been his object in
publishing the Institutes at Basle, appeals to his early depart
ure, after the publication, " patuit ex brevi discessu" Assum
ing, then, that there was an edition published previous to
August 1535, what becomes of the " early departure ?" If
the fancied edition was published in June or July, the
departure could not, in any proper sense of the term, be early,
if it did not take place in the course of the same year. And
yet, what is the fact ? We find Calvin dating a preface to
the Psychopannychia as still resident at Basle in 1536.
We are thus driven to the conclusion, that the edition of
Basle, in 1536, is the first, and that there must therefore be
either some inaccuracy in Calvin's statement, or some flaw in
the argument which employs that statement to prove that
the first edition did not contain the author's name on the
title-page.
Even were the former alternative adopted, there would
be nothing in it in the least degree derogatory to Calvin.
The statement in the preface to the Psalms was made in
1557, twenty-one years after the publication of the Institutes.
Would it be at all surprising, that after such a lapse of
time, one whose whole life had been occupied with great
thoughts and great transactions, should, through forget-
fulness, have spoken inaccurately of what, after all, is merely
a question of bibliography ; — a question which, owing to his