it, is as clearly revealed, as the doctrines concerning the nature of God, and person of the
Messiah, and the method of his redemption.
We find in Scripture, that all those of God’s professing people or visible saints who are
not truly pious,are represented as counterfeits,as having guile, disguise,and a false appearance,
as making false pretences, and as being deceitful and hypocrites.—Thus Christ says of Nath-
anael, John i. 47. “Behold an Israelite indeed, in whom is no guile;” that is, a truly gracious
person; implying, that those of God’s professing people, who are not gracious, are guileful,
and deceitful in their profession. So sinners in Zion, or in God’s visible church, are called
hypocrites. Isa. xxxiii. 14. “The sinners in Zion are afraid, fearfulness hath surprised the hy-
pocrites.” Isa. xi. 17. “Every one is an hypocrite and an evil-doer.” So they are called lying
children, Isa. xxx. 9. and chap. lix. 13. and are represented as lying, in pretending to be of
the temple or church of God. Jer. vii. 2, 4. “Hear the word of the Lord, all ye of Judah, that
enter in at these gates to worship the Lord.—Trust ye not in lying words, saying, The temple
of the Lord, the temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord are these.” These are spoken of
as falsely calling themselves of the holy city, Isa. xlviii. 1, 2.. They are called silverdross, and
reprobate or refuse silver, (Ezek. xxii. 18.. Jer. vi. 30..) which glisters and shows like true silver,
but has not its inward worth. So they are compared to adulterated wine, Isa. i. 22.. and to
trees full of leaves, bidding fair for fruitfulness, Matt. xxi. 19.. Clouds that look as if they were
full of rain, yet bring nothing but wind, Jude 12.. Wells without water, that do but cheat the
thirsty traveller, 2 Pet. ii. 13.. A deceitful bow, that appears good, but fails the archer, Psal.
lxxviii. 57.. Hos. vii. 16..—Mr. Stoddard, in his Appeal to the Learned, from time to time,
supposes all visible saints, who are not truly pious, to be hypocrites, as in page 15, 17, 18.
Now what ground or reason can there be thus to represent those to be visible saints, or
members of God’s visible church, who are not truly pious, if the profession of such does not
imply any pretence to true piety; and when they never made a pretence to any thing more
than common grace, or moral sincerity, which many of them truly have, and therefore are
not at all hypocritical or deceitful in their pretences, and are as much without guile, in what
they make a profession of, as Nathanael was? The psalmist speaking of sincere piety, calls
it truth in the inward parts. Psal. li. 6. “Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward parts.” It
is called truth with reference to some declaration or profession made by God’s visible people;
but on the hypothesis which I oppose, common grace is as properly truth in the inward parts,
in this respect, as saving grace. God says concerning Israel, Deut. xxxii. 5. “Their spot is not
the spot of his children.” God here speaks of himself, as it were, disappointed; the words
having reference to some profession they had made. For why should the remark be made,
after this manner, that spots appeared upon them, and showed marks that they were not his
children, if they never pretended to be his children, and never were accepted under any such
notion to any of the privileges of his people?
1786
SECTION IV. Reason requires a hearty profession.