392 INSTITUTES OF THE BOOK II.
mercy does not act alone," (August. Ep. 170, ad Vital. See
also Enchirid. ad Laurent, cap. 32.) This second proposi
tion being absurd, Augustine justly concludes the meaning of
the words to be, that there is no good will in man until it
is prepared by the Lord ; not that we ought not to will and
run, but that both are produced in us by God. Some, with
equal unskilfulness, wrest the saying of Paul, " We are
labourers together with God," (1 Cor. iii. 9.) There cannot be a doubt that these words apply to ministers only, who are
called " labourers with God," not from bringing any thing of their own, but because God makes use of their instrumen
tality after he has rendered them fit, and provided them with
the necessary endowments.
18. They appeal also to Ecclesiasticus, who is well known
to be a writer of doubtful authority. But, though we might
justly decline his testimony, let us see what he says in support
of free will. His words are, " He himself made man from
the beginning, and left him in the hand of his counsel ; If
thou wilt, to keep the commandments, and perform accept
able faithfulness. He hath set fire and water before thee :
stretch forth thy hand unto whether thou wilt. Before man
is life and death ; and whether him liketh shall be given him,"
(Ecclesiasticus xv. 14-17.) Grant that man received at his
creation a power of acquiring life or death ; what, then, if
we, on the other hand, can reply that he has lost it ? As
suredly I have no intention to contradict Solomon, who
asserts that " God hath made man upright ;" that fi they have
sought out many inventions," (Eccl. vii. 29.) But since man, by degenerating, has made shipwreck of himself and all his
blessings, it certainly does not follow, that every thing attri
buted to his nature, as originally constituted, applies to it
now when vitiated and degenerate. Therefore, not only to
my opponents, but to the author of Ecclesiasticus himself,
(whoever he may have been,) this is my answer : If you mean
to tell man that in himself there is a power of acquiring sal
vation, your authority with us is not so great as, in the least
degree, to prejudice the undoubted word of God ; but if only
wishing to curb the malignity of the flesh, which, by transfer
ring the blame of its own wickedness to God, is wont to catch