The
thirteen Pauline Epistles of our present Canon, and the Epistle to the
Hebrews. These formed for Eusebius an absolutely undisputed part of the
Canon (cf. chap. 25, below, where he speaks of them with the same
complete assurance), and were universally accepted until the present
century. The external testimony for all of them is ample, going back
(the Pastoral Epistles excepted) to the early part of the second
century. The Epistles to the Romans, Corinthians, and Galatians have
never been disputed (except by an individual here and there, especially
during the last few years in Holland), even the Tübingen School
accepting them as genuine works of Paul. The other epistles have not
fared so well. The genuineness of Ephesians was first questioned by
Usteri in 1824 and De Wette in 1826, and the Tübingen School
rejected it. Scholars are at present greatly divided; the majority of
negative critics reject it, while many liberal and all conservative
scholars defend it. Colossians was first attacked by Mayerhoff in 1838,
followed by the whole Tübingen School. It fares to-day somewhat
better than Ephesians. It is still, however, rejected by many extreme
critics, while others leave the matter in suspense (e.g.
Weizsäcker in his Apostolisches Zeitalter). Since 1872,
when the theory was proposed by Holtzmann, some scholars have held that
our present Epistle contains a genuine Epistle of Paul to the
Colossians, of which it is a later revision and expansion. Baur and the
Tübingen School were the first to attack Philippians as a whole,
and it too is still rejected by many critics, but at the same time it
is more widely accepted than either Ephesians or Colossians (e.g.
Weizsäcker and even Hilgenfeld defend its genuineness). Second
Thessalonians was first attacked by Schmidt in 1801, followed by a
number of scholars, until Baur extended the attack to the first Epistle
also. Second Thessalonians is still almost unanimously rejected by
negative critics, and even by some moderates, while First Thessalonians
has regained the support of many of the former (e.g. Hilgenfeld,
Weizsäcker, and even Holtzmann), and is entirely rejected by
comparatively few critics. Philemon—which was first attacked by
Baur—is quite generally accepted, but the Pastoral Epistles are
almost as generally rejected, except by the regular conservative school
(upon the Pastorals, see Bk. II. chap. 22, note 8, above). For a
concise account of the state of criticism upon each epistle, see
Holtzmann’s Einleitung. For a defense of them all, see the
Einleitung of Weiss.