After laying down as a thesis (§1) the
substantive existence of the divine Word or Wisdom, Athan. proceeds to
combat the idea that the Word has no personality distinct from that of
the Father. Setting aside the alternative errors of Sabellius (§2)
and Arius (§3), he taxes with the consequence of involving two
᾽Αρχαί a view that the Word had a
substantive existence and was then united to the Father (cf. Euseb.
c. Marcell. 32 A, 108 A, 106 C, D). This consequence can only be
avoided by falling into the Sabellian alternative of a θεὸς
διφυής (cf. Tertullian’s ‘Deum
versipellem’), unless the true solution, that of the eternal
divine γέννησις, be
accepted (§3 worked out in 4, 5). The argument, apparently
interrupted by an anti-Arian digression §§6, 7, is resumed
§8, whence it proceeds without break to §24. Eusebius,
insisting against Marcellus on the eternity of Christ’s Kingdom,
inconsistently defends those who deny the eternity of His Person. But
if so, how inconsistent are those who deny the Son any pre-existence,
while yet repelling the Arian formulæ with indignation! In
§§9–12, taking Joh. x. 30 as his text, Athan. asks his opponents
in what sense Christ and the Father ‘are one,’
distinguishing from his own answer that of Sabellius (9, 10), and that
of Marcellus (11, 12), whom he presses with the paradoxical character
of his explanation of the divine γέννησις. In
§§13, 14, he examines the (Marcellian, not Sabellian)
doctrine of πλατυσμὸς and
συστολή,
charging it with Sabellianism as its consequence. Next
(§§15–24) Ath. turns upon the radically weak point of
the system of Marcellus (Prolegg. ubi supra), and asks What do
his followers mean by ‘the Son?’ Do they mean merely
(a) the man, Christ (§20, Photinus), or (b) the
union of Word and Man, or (c) the Word regarded as Incarnate?
The latter was the answer (§22) of Marcellus himself. This last
point leads to a discussion (§24) of those O.T. passages on which
Marcellus notoriously relied. §25, which Zahn understands as a
direct polemic against Sabellius, is far more probably, as Newman
maintains in his note, a supplemental argument against Marcellianism,
for the view combated is said to lead inevitably to
Sabellianism. The concluding portion, §§26–36, turns
the argument of §24, that Scripture declares the identity of Son
and Word, against those who (adopting alternative (a) supra)
drift from Marcellianism toward the Samosatene rather than toward the
Sabellian position (on the connection of the two see Prolegg.
ch. ii. §3 (2) a and c). Even here, the name of Photinus, to whose
position the section specially applies, is significantly withheld.