64. Therefore if the works subsist ‘by will
and favour,’ and the whole creature is made ‘at God’s
good pleasure,’ and Paul was called to be an Apostle ‘by
the will of God,’ and our calling has come about ‘by His
good pleasure and will,’ and all things have come into being
through the Word, He is external to the things which have come to be by
will, but rather is Himself the Living Counsel of the Father, by which all these
things have come to be; by which David also gives thanks in the
seventy-second Psalm. ‘Thou hast holden me by my right hand; Thou
shalt guide me with Thy Counsel Ps. lxxiii. 23,
24..’ How
then can the Word, being the Counsel and Good Pleasure of the Father,
come into being Himself ‘by good pleasure and will,’ like
every one else? unless, as I said before, in their madness they repeat
that He has come into being through Himself, or through some other δι᾽ ἑτέρου
τινος. This idea has
been urged against the Arians again and again, as just above, §61;
e.g. de Decr. 8, 24; Or. i. 15, below 65, sub.
fin. vid. also Epiph. Hær. 76. p. 951. Basil. contr.
Eunom. ii. 11. c. 17, a. &c.. Who then is it through whom He has come to
be? let them fashion another Word; and let them name another Christ,
rivalling the doctrine of Valentinus §60.; for Scripture
it is not. And though they fashion another, yet assuredly he too comes
into being through some one; and so, while we are thus reckoning up and
investigating the succession of them, the many-headed πολυκέφαλος
αἵρεσις.
And so πολυκ.
πανουργία, §62. The allusion is to the hydra, with its
ever-springing heads, as introduced §58, n. 5. and with a special
allusion to Asterius who is mentioned, §60, and in de Syn.
18. is called πολυκ.
σοφιστής. heresy of the Atheists Or. ii. 43, n. 4. is discovered to issue in polytheism §16, n. 4. and madness unlimited; in the which, wishing
the Son to be a creature and from nothing, they imply the same thing in
other words by pretending the words will and pleasure, which rightly
belong to things originate and creatures. Is it not irreligious then to
impute the characteristics of things originate to the Framer of all?
and is it not blasphemous to say that will was in the Father before the
Word? for if will precedes in the Father, the Son’s words are not
true, ‘I in the Father;’ or even if He is in the Father,
yet He will hold but a second place, and it became Him not to say
‘I in the Father,’ since will was before Him, in which all
things were brought into being and He Himself subsisted, as you hold.
For though He excel in glory, He is not the less one of the things
which by will come into being. And, as we have said before, if it be
so, how is He Lord and they servants Or. i. 57; ii. 23.? but He is
Lord of all, because He is one with the Father’s Lordship; and
the creation is all in bondage, since it is external to the Oneness of
the Father, and, whereas it once was not, was brought to be.