268
17. This is evident from what Alexander,1928 bishop of Jerusalem and Theoctistus1929
of Cæsarea, wrote to Demetrius1930 in regard to the matter, defending themselves thus:
“He has stated in his letter that such a thing was never heard of before, neither has
hitherto taken place, that laymen should preach in the presence of bishops. I know not how
he comes to say what is plainly untrue.
18. For whenever persons able to instruct the brethren are found, they are exhorted by
the holy bishops to preach to the people. Thus in Laranda, Euelpis by Neon; and in Iconium,
tablished. It becomes, in time, the prerogative of the bishop to preach, and this prerogative he confers upon his
presbyters also (not universally, but in most cases), while deacons and laymen are almost everywhere excluded
from the right. We see from the present chapter, however, that the custom was not the same in all parts of the
Church in the time of Origen. The principle had evidently before this become firmly established in Alexandria
that only bishops and presbyters should preach. But in Palestine no such rule was recognized as binding. At the
same time, it is clear enough that it was exceptional even there for laymen to preach (in the presence of their
bishops), for Alexander in his epistle, instead of saying that laymen preach everywhere and of right, cites partic-
ular instances of their preaching, and says that where they are qualified they are especially requested by the
bishops to use their gifts; so that the theory that the prerogative belonged of right to the bishop existed there
just as truly as in Alexandria. Origen of course knew that he was acting contrary to the custom (if not the canon)
of his own church in thus preaching publicly, and yet undoubtedly he took it for granted that he was perfectly
right in doing what these bishops requested him to do in their own dioceses. They were supreme in their own
churches, and he knew of nothing, apparently, which should hinder him from doing what they approved of,
while in those churches. Demetrius, however, thought otherwise, and considered the public preaching of an
unordained man irregular, in any place and at any time. Whether jealousy of Origen’s growing power had anything
to do with his action it is difficult to say with certainty. He seems to have treated Origen in a perfectly friendly
way after his return; and yet it is possible that the difference of opinion on this point, and the reproof given by
Demetrius, may not have been wholly without influence upon their subsequent relations, which became in the
end so painful (see chap. 8, note 4).
1928 On Alexander, see chap. 8, note 6.
1929 Theoctistus, bishop of Cæsarea, seems to have been one of the most influential bishops of the East in
his day, and played a prominent part in the controversy which arose in regard to Novatus, as we learn from
chap. 46 of this book and from chap. 5 of the next. He was also a firm friend of Origen’s for many years (see
chap. 27), probably until the latter’s death. We do not know the dates of his accession and of his death, but we
find him already bishop in the year 216, and still bishop at the time of the episcopate of Stephen of Rome
(254–257; see Bk. VII. chap. 5), but already succeeded by Domnus, when Xystus was bishop of Rome (257–258;
see Bk. VII. chap. 14). We must, therefore, put his death between 255 and 258.
1930 Eusebius is apparently mistaken in stating that this epistle was addressed to Demetrius, for the latter is
spoken of throughout the epistle in the third person. It seems probable that Eusebius has made a slip and said
“to Demetrius” when he meant to say “concerning Demetrius.”
661
Circumstances Related of Origen.