With regard to the date of Cat. iv., which
contains a brief preliminary statement of all the articles of the
Creed, we may obtain some evidence from an incident recorded in a
letter of Jerome Ep. 61 (al.
38). Cf. Ben. Ed. Praeloq. ad Cat. iv. pp. 49,
50. to Pammachius.
John, who had then succeeded Cyril as Bishop of Jerusalem, had on a
certain occasion discoursed on the Creed and all the doctrines of the
Church in the presence of Epiphanius and the whole congregation.
Jerome, being ignorant of the peculiar custom of the Church of
Jerusalem, rebukes the supposed presumption of the Bishop, “that
a man deficient in eloquence should in one discourse in Church discuss
all the doctrines concerning the Trinity, the Incarnation, the
Crucifixion, the descent into hell, the nature of angels, the state of
departed souls, the Resurrection of Christ, and of ourselves, and other
subjects.” The rebuke calls out a statement from
John: “The custom among us is that for forty days we
publicly deliver the doctrine of the Holy and Adorable Trinity to those
who are to be baptized.” This being the custom at Jerusalem
in Cyril’s time, we may conjecture that Cat. iv., which
corresponds closely to the description of John’s discourse, was
delivered, like that, on a Sunday before the whole congregation:
and this is in fact suggested by Cyril’s own words in §
3: “Let those here present, whose habit of mind is mature,
and who have their senses already exercised to discern good and
evil, endure patiently to listen to things fitted rather for
children.” That this could not have been later than the
Sunday following that on which the Procatechesis was delivered, is
shewn by the mention in the same section of “the long interval of
the days of all this holy Quadragesima,” an expression which
could not well have been used later than the second Sunday in
Lent.