foe? He cannot tell us that, or he manifestly contradicts himself, for he owns that by his de-
fault he received the adverse verdict. If it was a duty to speak at the actual time of the trial
(for that is the law which he lays down for us in his book), then why was he then condemned
by default? If on the other hand he did well in observing silence before such dicasts, how
arbitrarily87 he praises himself, but blames us, for silence at such a time! What can be more
absurdly unjust than this! When two treatises have been put forth since the time of the trial,
he declares that his apology, though written so very long after, was in time, but reviles that
which answered his own as quite too late! Surely he ought to have abused Basil’s intended
counter-statement before it was actually made; but this is not found amongst his other
complaints. Knowing as he did what Basil was going to write when the time of the trial had
passed away, why in the world did he not find fault with it there and then? In fact it is clear
from his own confession that he never made that apology in the trial itself. I will repeat again
his words:—‘We confess that we were condemned by default;’ and he adds why; ‘Evil-disposed
persons had been passed as jurymen,’ or rather, to use his own phrase, ‘there was a packed
panel of them where a jury ought to have sat.’ Whereas, on the other hand, it is clear from
another passage in his book that he attests that his apology was made ‘at the proper time.’
It runs thus:—“That I was urged to make this apology at the proper time and in the proper
manner from no pretended reasons, but compelled to do so on behalf of those who went
security for me, is clear from facts and also from this man’s words.” He adroitly twists his
words round to meet every possible objection; but what will he say to this? ‘It was not right
to keep silent during the trial.’ Then why was Eunomius speechless during that same trial?
And why is his apology, coming as it did after the trial, in good time? And if in good time,
why is Basil’s controversy with him not in good time?
But the remark of that holy father is especially true, that Eunomius in pretending to
make an apology really gave his teaching the support he wished to give it; and that genuine
emulator of Phineas’ zeal, destroying as he does with the sword of the Word every spiritual
fornicator, dealt in the ‘Answer to his blasphemy’ a sword-thrust that was calculated at once
to heal a soul and to destroy a heresy. If he resists that stroke, and with a soul deadened by
apostacy will not admit the cure, the blame rests with him who chooses the evil, as the
Gentile proverb says. So far for Eunomius’ treatment of truth, and of us: and now the law
of former times, which allows an equal return on those who are the first to injure, might
prompt us to discharge on him a counter-shower of abuse, and, as he is a very easy subject
for this, to be very liberal of it, so as to outdo the pain which he has inflicted: for if he was
so rich in insolent invective against one who gave no chance for calumny, how many of
such epithets might we not expect to find for those who have satirized that saintly life? But
we have been taught from the first by that scholar of the Truth to be scholars of the Gospel
87 τίς ἡ ἀποκλήρωσις: this is a favourite word with Origen and Gregory.
80
In charging Basil with not defending his faith at the time of the 'Trials,'…