II. (c. 5–17). That there is no difference
(morally) between one who fasts and one who takes food with
thanksgiving. Jovinian has quoted (5) many texts of Scripture to show
that God has made animals for men’s food. But (6) there are many
other uses of animals besides food. And there are many warnings like
1 Cor. vi. 13, as to the danger arising from food.
There are among the heathen (7) many instances of abstinence. They
recognize (8) the evil of sensual allurements, and often, like Crates
the Theban, (9) have cast away what would tempt them; the senses, they
teach, (10) should be subject to reason; and, that (11) except for
athletes (Christians do not want to be like Milo of Crotona) bread and
water suffice. Horace (12), Xenophon and other eminent Greeks (13), the
Essenes and the Brahmans (14), as well as philosophers like Diogenes,
testify to the value of abstinence. The Old Testament stories (15) of
Esau’s pottage, of the lusting of Israel for the flesh-pots of
Egypt, and those in the New Testament of Anna, Cornelius, &c.,
commend abstinence. If some heretics inculcate fasting (16) in such a
way as to despise the gifts of God, and weak Christians are not to be
judged for their use of flesh, those who seek the higher life (17) will
find a help in abstinence.