46. Let then all contention cease, nor let us any longer conflict, though the
Councils have differently taken the phrase ‘Coessential,’
for we have already assigned a sufficient defence of them; and to it
the following may be added:—We have not derived the word
‘Unoriginate’ from Scripture, (for no where does Scripture
call God Unoriginate,) yet since it has many authorities in its favour,
I was curious about the term, and found that it too has different
senses [In
this passage the difficulties and confusion which surround the
terms ἀγένητος and ἀγέννητος (supr. p. 149, &c.) come to a head. The question
is (assuming, as proved by Lightfoot, the validity of the distinction
of the two in Athan.) which word is to be read here. The mss. are divided throughout between the two readings, but
it is clear (so Lightf. and Zahn on Ign. Eph. 7) that one word
alone is in view throughout the present passage. That word, then, is
pronounced by Lightf., partly on the strength of the quotation from the
unnamed teachers (infr. note 7), partly on the ground of a
reference to §26 (see note 10 there), to be ἀγέννητος. With all deference to so great an authority, I cannot
hesitate to pronounce for ἀγένητος. (1.) The parallelism of the two senses with the third and fourth
senses of ἀγέν.
Orat. i. 30. is almost decisive by itself. (2.) Ath.’s
explanation of Ignatius. viz. that Christ is γένητος on account of the flesh (he
would have referred γέννητος to His Essence, Orat. i. 56, certainly not to the
flesh), while as Son and Word He is distinct from γένητα and ποιήματα, is even more decisive. (3.) His explanation §46,
sub fin. that the Son is ἀγένητος because He is ἀΐδιον
γέννημα would lose all sense if ἀγέννητος were read. As a matter of fact, ἀγέννητος is the specific, ἀγένητος the generic term: the former was not applicable to the Eternal
Son; the latter was, except in the first of the two senses
distinguished in the text; a sense, however, more properly coming under
the specific idea of ἀγέννητος. This was the ambiguity which made the similarity of the
two words so dangerous a weapon in Arian hands. The above note does not
of course affect the true reading of Ign. Eph. 7, as to which
Lightfoot and Zahn speak with authority: but it seems clear that
Athan., however mistakenly, quotes Ign. with the reading
ἀγένητος.]. Some, for instance, call what is, but
is neither generated, nor has any personal cause at all, unoriginate;
and others, the uncreate. As then a person, having in view the former
of these senses, viz. ‘that which has no personal cause,’
might say that the Son was not unoriginate, yet would not blame any one
whom he perceived to have in view the other meaning, ‘not a work
or creature but an eternal offspring,’ and to affirm accordingly
that the Son was unoriginate, (for both speak suitably with a view to
their own object); so, even granting that the Fathers have spoken
variously concerning the Coessential, let us not dispute about it, but
take what they deliver to us in a religious way, when especially their
anxiety was directed in behalf of religion.