The information which is given us here in regard to the methods of
the Theodotians is very interesting. What is said in regard to their
philosophical principles makes it evident that they used the
grammatical and critical mode of exegesis as opposed to the prevalent
allegorical mode. Nothing could seem more irreverent and irreligious to
the Church of that age than such a method of interpretation, the method
which we now recognize as the only true one. They were, moreover,
textual critics. They may have been rash in their methods, but it is
not necessary to suppose them dishonest in their purposes. They seem to
have looked upon the Scriptures as inspired as truly as their opponents
did, but they believed that radical criticism was needed if the true
reading of the originals was to be reached, while their opponents were
shocked at anything of the kind. That textual criticism was necessary,
even at that early day, is clear enough from the words of Irenæus
(quoted in chap. 20, above), and from the words of Dionysius (quoted in
Bk. IV. chap. 23), as well as from many other sources. Finally, these
men seem to have offended their opponents by the use of dialectical
methods in their treatment of theology. This is very significant at
that early date. It is indeed the earliest instance known to us of that
method which seemed entirely irreligious to the author of the Little
Labyrinth, but which less than a century later prevailed in the
Antiochian school, and for a large part of the Middle Ages ruled the
whole Church.