Hilary’s speculative thought, like that of every serious adherent of the pagan creed, had
certainly been inspired by Neoplatonism. We cannot take the account of his spiritual progress
up to the full Catholic faith, which he gives in the beginning of the De Trinitate, and of
which we find a less finished sketch in the Homily on Psalm lxi. § 2, as literal history. It is
too symmetrical in its advance through steadily increasing light to the perfect knowledge,
too well prepared as a piece of literary workmanship—it is indeed an admirable example of
majestic prose, a worthy preface to that great treatise—for us to accept it, as it stands, as the
record of actual experience. But we may safely see in it the evidence that Hilary had been
an earnest student of the best thought of his day, and had found in Neoplatonism not only
a speculative training but also the desire, which was to find its satisfaction in the Faith, for
knowledge of God, and for union with Him. It was a debt which Origen, his master, shared
with him; and it must have been because, as a Neoplatonist feeling after the truth, he found
v
so much of common ground in Origen, that he was able to accept so fully the teaching of
Alexandria. But it would be impossible to separate between the lessons which Hilary had
learnt from the pagan form of this philosophy, and those which may have been new to him
when he studied it in its Christian presentment. Of the influence of Christian Platonism
upon him something will be said shortly. At this point we need only mention as a noteworthy
indication of the fact that Hilary was not unmindful of the debt, that the only philosophy
which he specifically attacks is the godless system of Epicurus, which denies creation, declares
that the gods do not concern themselves with men, and deifies water or earth or atoms20.
It was, then, as a man of mature age, of literary skill and philosophical training, that
Hilary approached Christianity. He had been drawn towards the Faith by desire for a truth
which he had not found in philosophy; and his conviction that this truth was Christianity
was established by independent study of Scripture, not by intercourse with Christian
teachers; so much we may safely conclude from the early pages of the De Trinitate. It must
remain doubtful whether the works of Origen, who influenced his thought so profoundly,
had fallen into his hands before his conversion, or whether it was as a Christian, seeking for
further light upon the Faith, that he first studied them. For it is certainly improbable that
he would find among the Christians of his own district many who could help him in intel-
lectual difficulties. The educated classes were still largely pagan, and the Christian body,
which was, we may say, unanimously and undoubtingly Catholic, held, without much
mental activity, a traditional and inherited faith. Into this body Hilary entered by Baptism,
at some unknown date. His age at the time, his employment, whether or no he was married21,
20 Tract. in Ps. i. 7, lxi. 2, lxiii. 5, &c. As usual, Hilary does not name his opponents.
21 Hilary’s legendary daughter Abra, to whom he is said to have written a letter printed in the editions of his
works, is now generally abandoned by the best authorities, e.g. by Fechtrup, the writer, in Wetzer-Welte’s En-
cyclopædia, of the best short life of Hilary.
11
The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of Poitiers.