82. Let us, however, make answer to the conclusion they strive to establish; but we seem
to have sought, in pursuit of a personal appeal, to escape from the difficulty of treating the
question before us. The Father, they say, has begotten a Son; the Son has not. What proof
is this that they are not equal? To beget is the Father’s natural function, as a Father, and no
necessary outcome of His Sovereign Power.1622 Furthermore, dutiful regard places persons
on an equality with each other, and does not sunder them. Again, our own experience of
what holds good amongst us frail mortals teaches us that it may frequently happen that
weak men have sons, whilst stronger men have not; that slaves have children, whilst their
masters are childless; and that the poor beget offspring, whilst rich men are unblessed with
any.
83. But if our adversaries say that this too may be the result of infirmity, inasmuch as
men may desire to beget children, but be unable to do so; then, though things divine are
not to be judged of and determined by things human, yet let them understand that with
men also, as with God, whether one has children or no, is not dependent upon or derived
of his authoritative power, but upon the personal attributes of a father, and that begetting
lies not in the power of our will, but is contingent upon our qualities of body; for if it were
a matter of sovereign authority, then the mightier king would have the greater number of
sons. To have sons, then, or to be childless, therefore, is not in necessary connection or re-
lation to sovereign authority. Is it, then, so with nature?
84. If you [my Arian adversaries] regard what you object as natural weakness, and rely
upon examples taken from the nature of mankind, remember that the Father’s nature is the
273
same as the Son’s, and therefore you do either confess the Son to be a true Son, and dishonour
the Father in the Person of the Son, by reason of Their unity in one and the same Nature
(for as the Father is by Nature God, so also is the Son; whereas the Apostle says that the
“gods many” are not so by nature, but are only so called); or, if you deny Him to be a true
Son, that is to say, possessing the same Nature, then He is not begotten, and if the Son is
not begotten, the Father did not beget Him.
85. The conclusion we come at, therefore, on the line of your persuasion, is that God
the Father is not Almighty, because He could not beget, if He did not beget the Son, but
created Him. But forasmuch as the Father is Almighty, He being, as you hold, the Almighty
in so far as He is the only Author of Being, then surely He has begotten His Son, and not
created Him. Howbeit, we ought to believe His word before yours. He says: “I have begot-
ten,”1623 and that more than once, witnessing to Himself as begetting.
86. It is no sign, then, of infirmity, whether of nature or authority, in Christ, that He
has not begotten, for to beget, as we have already said ofttimes, bears no relation to supremacy
1622 i.e.,the Father begets quâ Father, not quâ Almighty (ὁ Παντοκράτωρ).
1623 Ps. cx. 3.
608
Chapter VIII. The heretical objection, that the Son cannot be equal to the…