(2.) With the accession of Constantius to sole
power, the anti-Nicene reaction at last had a free hand throughout the
Empire. Of what elements did it now consist? The original reaction was
conservative in its numerical strength, Arian in its motive power. The
stream was derived from the two fountain heads of Paul of Samosata, the
ancestor of Arius, and of Origen the founder of the theology of the
Eastern Church generally and especially of that of Eusebius of
Cæsarea. Flowing from such heterogeneous sources, the two currents
never thoroughly mingled. Common action, dictated on the one hand by
dread of Sabellianism, manipulated on the other hand by wire-pullers in
the interest of Arianism, united the East till after the death of
Constantine in the campaign against the leaders of Nicæa. Then for
the last ten years of the life of Constans, Arianism, or rather the
Reaction, had its ‘stationary period’ (Newman). The chaos
of creeds at the Council of Antioch (supr. p. xliv.) shewed the
presence of discordant aims; but opposition to Western interference,
and the urgent panic of Photinus and his master, kept them together:
the lead was still taken by the Arianisers, as is shewn by the
continued prominence of the fourth Antiochene Creed at Philippopolis
(343), Antioch (344), and Sirmium (351). But the second or Lucianic
Creed was on record as the protest of the conservative majority, and
was not forgotten. Yet until after 351, when Photinus was finally got
rid of and Constantius master of the world, the reaction was still
embodied in a fairly compact and united party. But now the latent
heterogeneity of the reaction began to make itself felt. Differing in
source and motive, the two main currents made in different directions.
The influence of Aristotle and Paul and Lucian set steadily toward a
harder and more consistent Arianism, that of Plato and the Origenists
toward an understanding with the Nicenes.