240 JEROME.
lest he should be held guilty of maintaining
with Pythagoras the transmigration of souls, he winds up the wicked reasoning with which
he has wounded his reader by saying : " I must not be taken to make dogmas of these things ;
they are only thrown out as conjectures to
shew that they are not altogether overlooked." 5. In his second book he maintains a plural- ity of worlds ; not, however, as Epicurus
taught, many like ones existing at once, but a
new one beginning each time that the old
comes to an end. There was a world before
this world of ours, and after it there will be
first one and then another and so on in regu- lar succession. He is in doubt whether one
world shall be so completely similar to another
as to leave no room for any difference between
them, or whether one world shall ne^er
wholly be indistinguishable from another.
And again a little farther on he writes : "if, as the course of the discussion makes neces-
sary, all things can live without body, all
bodily existence shall be swallowed up and
that which once has been made out of nothing
shall again be reduced to nothing. And yet a time will come when its use will be once
more necessary." And in the same context :
41 but if, as reason and the authority of script- ure shew, this corruptible shall put on
incorruption and this mortal shall put on
immortality, death shall be swallowed up in
victory an<j corruption in incorruption. ' And it may be that all bodily existence shall be
removed, for it is only in this that death can
operate." And a little farther on : " if these things are not contrary to the faith, it may be
that we shall some day live in a disembodied
state. Moreover, if only he is fully subject to
Christ who is disembodied, and if all must be
made subject to Him, we too shall lose our
bodies when we become fully subject to Him."
And in the same passage : " if all are to be made subject to God, all shall lay aside their
bodies ; and then all bodily existence shall be
brought to nought. But if through the fall of
reasonable beings it is a second time required
it will reappear. For God has left souls to
strive and struggle, to teach them that full
and complete victory is to be attained not by
their own efforts but by His grace. And so
to my mind worlds vary with the sins which
cause them, and those are exploded theories
which maintain that all worlds are alike."
And again : " three conjectures occur to me with regard to the end ; it is for the reader to
determine which is nearest to the truth. For
either we shall be bodiless when being made
subject to Christ we shall be made subject to
God and He shall be all in all ; or as things
1 i Cor. xv. 53,54.
made subject to Christ shall be with Christ
Himself made subject to God and brought
under one law, so all substance shall be re-
fined into its most perfect form and rarified
into aether which is a pure and uncompounded
essence ; or else the sphere which I have called motionless and all that it contains will
be dissolved into nothing, and the sphere in
which the antizone ' itself is contained shall be
called 'good ground,'2 and that other sphere which in its revolution surrounds the earth
and goes by the name of heaven shall be
reserved for the abode of the saints." 6. In speaking thus does he not most
clearly follow the error of the heathen and
foist upon the simple faith of Christians the
ravings of philosophy? In the same book he
writes : " it remains that God is invisible.
But if He is by nature invisible, He must be
so even. to the Saviour." And lower down: " no soul which has descended into a human
body has borne upon it so true an impress of
its previous character as Christ's soul of which He says : ' no man taketh it from me, but I
lay it down of myself.' " 3 And in another
place: "we must carefully consider whether souls, when they have won salvation and have
attained to the blessed life, may not cease to be souls. For as the Lord and Saviour came
to seek and to save that which was lost " that it might cease to be lost ; so the lost soul
which the Lord came to save, when saved,
will cease to be a soul. We must ask our-
selves whether, as the lost was not lost once
and again will not be, the soul likewise may
have been and again may be not a soul." And after a good many remarks upon the
soul he brings in the following, " rovs or intelligence by falling becomes a soul ; and by
acquiring virtue this will become intelligence
again. This at least is a fair inference from
the case of Esau who for his old sins is con-
demned to lead a lower life. And concerning
the heavenly bodies we must make a similar
acknowledgment. The soul of the sun — or
whatever else you like to call it — does not date its existence from the creation of the
world ; it already existed before it entered its
shining and glowing body. So also with the moon and stars. From antecedent causes
they have been made subject to vanity not
willingly but for future reward/' and are forced to do not their own will but the cre-
ator's who has assigned to them their several
spheres."
7. Hellfire, moreover, and the torments with
1 This word is doubtful. 2 Matt. xiii. 8.
1 Job. x. 18. 4 Luke xix. 10.
6 The paralogism in this reasoning — so obvious to modern
minds — is due to the confusion of the copula with the verb sub- stantive.
6 Rom. viii. 20.