22. But
now I will turn the tables and put my accuser to the question. Tell me,
O great master, if there is anything to blame in a writer, is the blame
to be laid on one who reads or translates his works? Heaven forbid, he
will say; certainly not; why do you try to circumvent me by your
enigmatical questions? Am not I myself both a reader and a translator
of Origen? Read my translations and see if you can find any one of his
peculiar doctrines in them; especially any of those which I now mark
for condemnation. When driven to the point he says:
“If you wish thoroughly to
see how abhorent the very suggestion of such doctrines has always been
to me, read my Commentaries on the Epistle of Paul to the Ephesians,
and you will see from what I have written there what an opinion I
formed of him from reading and translating his works.”
2858
I ask, can we accept this man as
a great and grave teacher, who in one of his works praises Origen and
in another condemns him? who in his Introductions calls him a master
second only to the Apostles, but now calls him a heretic? What heretic,
I ask, was ever called a master of the churches? “It is true, he
replies, I was wrong about this but why do you go on bringing up this
unfortunate Preface
2859
against me?
Read my Commentaries, and especially those which I have
designated.” Is there any one who will think this satisfactory?
He has composed a great many books, in almost all of which he trumpets
forth the praises of Origen to the skies: these books through all these
years have been read and are being read by all men: many of these
readers after accepting his opinions have left this world and gone into
the presence of the Lord. They hold the opinion about Origen which they
had learnt from the statements of this man, and they departed in hope
that, according to this man’s assurance, they would find him
there as a master second only to the Apostles; but if we are to trust
his present writings, they have found him in a state of condemnation,
among the impious heretics and the heathen. Is this man now to turn
round from his former contention, and to say, “For some thirty
years I have been, in my studies and in my writings, praising Origen as
equal to the Apostles, but now I pronounce him a heretic?” How is
this? Has he come upon some new books of his which he had never read
before? Not at all. It is from these same sayings of Origen that he
formerly called him an Apostle and now calls him a heretic. But it is
impossible that this should really have been so. For either he was
right in his former praises, and his judgment has since been perverted
by some kind of extreme ill feeling, and in that case no attention is
to be paid to him; or else his former praises were mistaken, and he is
now condemning himself, and in that case what judgment does he think
others will pass upon him, when, according to the words of the
Apostle,
2860
he passes condemnation on
himself.
22 (
a
). But,
“Surely,” he says, “this judgment is done away with
since I have repented.” Not so fast! We all err, it is true, and
especially in word; and we all may repent of our errors. But can a man
do penance, and accuse others, and judge and condemn them, all in the
same moment? That would be as if a harlot who had abstained from her
harlotry for a night or two, should feel called upon to begin writing
laws in favour of chastity, and not only to enact these laws, but to
proceed to throw down the monuments of all the women who have died,
because she suspected that they had led lives like her own. You do
penance for having formerly been a heretic, and you do right. But what
has that to do with me who never was a heretic at all? You are right in
doing penance for your error: but the true way of doing penance is, not
by accusing others but by crying for mercy, not by condemning but by
weeping. For what sincerity can there be in penitence when the penitent
makes a decree of indulgence for himself? He who repents of what he has
spoken ill does not cure his
wound by speaking ill again,
but by keeping silence. For thus it is written:
2861
“Thou hast sinned, be at
peace.” But now you first bring yourself in a criminal, then you
absolve yourself from your crime, and forthwith change yourself from a
criminal into a judge. This may be no trouble to you who thus mock at
us, but it is a trouble to us if we suffer ourselves to be mocked by
you.
2858
The words are not quoted literally from Jerome’s letter to
Pammachius and Oceanus (Ep. lxxxiv. c. 2) the passage referred to; but
they give the sense fairly well. See also the letter to Vigilantius
(lxi. c. 2).
2859
Prœfati unculam
. That is, the
Preface to Origen’s Song of Songs, in which he says that Origen
has not only surpassed every one else, but also in this work has
surpassed himself.
2860
Perhaps from
1 Cor. xi. 29
, or
Rom. xiv. 23
2861
Possibly a kind of paraphrase of our Lord’s words to the
woman taken in adultery.
John viii. 11