This correspondence
which Hilary has preserved (Fragm. xiii.–xv.) is interesting as
shewing how difficult it must have been for the laity to determine who
was, and who was not, a heretic, when all parties used the same
Scriptural terms in commendation of themselves and condemnation of
their opponents. It begins with a public letter in which
Germinius makes a declaration of faith in Homoeousion terms, without
any mention of the reasons which had induced him to depart from the
Homoean position. This is followed by a reproachful letter, also
intended for publicity, from Valens, Ursacius, and others. They
had refused to attend to the rumour of his defection; but now are
compelled, by his own published letter, to ask the plain question,
whether or not he adheres to ‘the Catholic Faith set forth and
confirmed by the Holy Council at Rimini.’ If he had added
to the Homoean formula, which was that the Son is ‘like the
Father,’ the words ‘in substance’ or ‘in all
things,’ he had fallen into the justly condemned heresy of Basil
of Ancyra. They demand an explicit statement that he never had
said, and never would say, anything of the kind; and warn him that he
is gravely suspected, complaints of his teaching having been made by
certain of his clergy to neighbouring bishops, which they trust will be
proved groundless. Germinius made no direct reply to this letter,
but addressed a manifesto to a number of more sympathetic bishops,
containing the scriptural proofs of the divinity of Christ and
recalling the fact that the Homoean leaders, before their own victory,
had acquiesced in the Homoeousian confession. Any teaching to the
contrary is the work, not of God, but of the spirit of this world, and
he entreats those whom he addresses to circulate his letter as widely
as possible, lest any should fall through ignorance into the snares of
the devil. Germinius was assured of safety in writing thus.
Valentinian’s support of Auxentius had proved that bishops might
hold what opinions they would on the great question provided they were
not avowed Arians. Germinius had been a leader of the Homoean
party, and it is at least possible that his change of front was due to
his knowledge that the Emperor, though he would not eject Homoeans, had
no sympathy with them and would allow them no influence. In fact,
the smaller the share of conscience, the greater the historical
interest of Germinius’ action as shewing the decline of Homoean
influence in the West.