same and always has been. And perhaps no better proof of the Western acceptance of the
Eastern doctrine concerning the eternal procession of the Holy Spirit can be found than the
fact that St. John Damascene has been in recent years raised by the pope for his followers
to the rank of a Doctor of the Catholic Church.
169
Perhaps I may be allowed to close with two moderate statements of the Western position,
the one by the learned and pious Dr. Pusey and the other by the none less famous Bishop
Pearson.
Dr. Pusey says:
“Since, however, the clause, which found its way into the Creed, was, in the first instance,
admitted, as being supposed to be part of the Constantinopolitan Creed, and, since after it
had been rooted for 200 years, it was not uprooted, for fear of uprooting also or perplexing
the faith of the people, there was no fault either in its first reception or in its subsequent
retention.”
“The Greeks would condemn forefathers of their own, if they were to pronounce the
clause to be heretical. For it would be against the principles of the Church to be in commu-
nion with an heretical body. But from the deposition of Photius, a.d. 886 to at least a.d.
1009, East and West retained their own expression of faith without schism.224”
“a.d. 1077, Theophylact did not object to the West, retaining for itself the confession of
faith contained in the words, but only excepted against the insertion of the words in the
Creed.225”
And Bp. Pearson, explaining Article VIII. of the Creed says: “Now although the addition
of words to the formal Creed without the consent, and against the protestations of the Ori-
ental Church be not justifiable; yet that which was added is nevertheless a certain truth, and
may be so used in that Creed by them who believe the same to be a truth; so long as they
pretend it not to be a definition of that Council, but an addition or explication inserted, and
condemn not those who, out of a greater respect to such synodical determinations, will admit
of no such insertions, nor speak any other language than the Scriptures and their Fathers
spoke.”
224 Peter of Antioch about a.d. 1054, says that he had heard the name of the Roman Pontiff recited from the
Diptychs at the mass at Constantinople forty-five years before. Le Quien, p. xii.
225 E. B. Pusey. On the clause “and the Son,” p. 72.
337
Historical Excursus on the Introduction into the Creed of the Words “and…