Chapter 5.—In What Manner the Mathematicians are Convicted of Professing a Vain
Science.
Do not those very persons whom the medical sagacity of Hippocrates led him to suspect
to be twins, because their disease was observed by him to develop to its crisis and to subside
again in the same time in each of them,—do not these, I say, serve as a sufficient refutation
of those who wish to attribute to the influence of the stars that which was owing to a simil-
arity of bodily constitution? For wherefore were they both sick of the same disease, and at
the same time, and not the one after the other in the order of their birth? (for certainly they
could not both be born at the same time.) Or, if the fact of their having been born at different
times by no means necessarily implies that they must be sick at different times, why do they
contend that the difference in the time of their births was the cause of their difference in
other things? Why could they travel in foreign parts at different times, marry at different
times, beget children at different times, and do many other things at different times, by
reason of their having been born at different times, and yet could not, for the same reason,
also be sick at different times? For if a difference in the moment of birth changed the
horoscope, and occasioned dissimilarity in all other things, why has that simultaneousness
which belonged to their conception remained in their attacks of sickness? Or, if the destinies
of health are involved in the time of conception, but those of other things be said to be at-
tached to the time of birth, they ought not to predict anything concerning health from ex-
amination of the constellations of birth, when the hour of conception is not also given, that
its constellations may be inspected. But if they say that they predict attacks of sickness
without examining the horoscope of conception, because these are indicated by the moments
of birth, how could they inform either of these twins when he would be sick, from the
horoscope of his birth, when the other also, who had not the same horoscope of birth, must
of necessity fall sick at the same time? Again, I ask, if the distance of time between the births
of twins is so great as to occasion a difference of their constellations on account of the dif-
ference of their horoscopes, and therefore of all the cardinal points to which so much influ-
ence is attributed, that even from such change there comes a difference of destiny, how is
it possible that this should be so, since they cannot have been conceived at different times?
Or, if two conceived at the same moment of time could have different destinies with respect
to their births, why may not also two born at the same moment of time have different des-
tinies for life and for death? For if the one moment in which both were conceived did not
hinder that the one should be born before the other, why, if two are born at the same moment,
should anything hinder them from dying at the same moment? If a simultaneous conception
allows of twins being differently affected in the womb, why should not simultaneousness of
birth allow of any two individuals having different fortunes in the world? and thus would
all the fictions of this art, or rather delusion, be swept away. What strange circumstance is
this, that two children conceived at the same time, nay, at the same moment, under the same
In What Manner the Mathematicians are Convicted of Professing a Vain Science.
215
In What Manner the Mathematicians are Convicted of Professing a Vain Sc…