It has been said by Harnack that the theology of
Athanasius underwent no development, but was the same from first to
last. The truth of this verdict is I think limited by the fact that the
Origenism of Athanasius distinctly undergoes a change, or rather fades
away, in his later works. A non-Origenist element is present from the
first, and after the contest with Arianism begins, Origen’s ideas
recede more and more from view. Athanasius was influenced
negatively by the stress of the Arian controversy: while the
vague and loose Origenism of the current Greek theology inclined the
majority of bishops to dread Sabellianism rather than Arianism, and to
underrate the danger of the latter (pp. xviii., xxxv.), Athanasius,
deeply impressed, from personal
experience, with the negation of the first principles of redemption
which Arianism involved, stood apart from the first from the theology
of his Asiatic contemporaries and went back to the authority of
Scripture and the Rule of Faith. He was influenced positively by
the Nicene formula, which represents the combination of Western with
anti-Origenist Eastern traditions in opposition to the dominant Eastern
theology. The Nicene formula found in Athanasius a mind predisposed to
enter into its spirit, to employ in its defence the richest resources
of theological and biblical training, of spiritual depth and vigour, of
self-sacrificing but sober and tactful enthusiasm; its victory in the
East is due under God to him alone.