502
Chapter 5.—8. Aurelius of Utica1767 said: "Since the apostle says that we ought not to
be partakers with the sins of other men,1768 what else does he do but make himself partaker
with the sins of other men, who holds communion with heretics without the baptism of the
Church? And therefore I pronounce my judgment that heretics should be baptized, that
they may receive remission of their sins, and so communion be allowed to them."1769
9. The answer is: Therefore Cyprian and all those bishops were partakers in the sins
of other men, inasmuch as they remained in communion with such men, when they removed
no one from the right of communion who entertained a different opinion. Where, then, is
the Church? Then, to say nothing for the moment of heretics,—since the words of this
judgment are applicable also to other sinners, such as Cyprian saw with lamentation to be
in the Church with him, whom, while he confuted them, he yet tolerated,—where is the
Church, which, according to these words must be held to have perished from that very
moment by the contagion of their sins? But if, as is the most firmly established truth, the
Church both has remained and does remain, the partaking of the sins of others, which is
forbidden by the apostle, must be considered only to consist in consenting to them. But let
heretics be baptized again, that they may receive remission of their sins, if the wayward and
the envious are baptized again, who, seeing that "they renounced the world in words and
not in deeds," were indeed able to receive baptism, but did not obtain remission of their
sins, as the Lord says, "If ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive
your trespasses."1770
1767 Utica, the well-known city in ecclesiastical province of Zeugitana. The Aurelius of Cypr. Epp. xxvii. 4,
lvii. and lxvii. (the first) are more likely to be identical with the bishop of Utica, than with the Aurelius of
Chullabis, who delivers his opinion the 81st in order.
1768 1 Tim. v. 22.
1769 Conc. Carth. sec. 41.
1770 Matt. vi. 15.
Chapter 5
925
Chapter 5