Once more, let them say whether things originate
could say John xvi. 15., ‘all things whatsoever the
Father hath are Mine.’ Now, He has the prerogative of creating
and making, of Eternity, of omnipotence, of immutability. But things
originate cannot have the power of making, for they are creatures; nor
eternity, for their existence has a beginning; nor of omnipotence and
immutability, for they are under sway, and of changeable nature, as the
Scriptures say. Well then, if these prerogatives belong to the Son,
they clearly do so, not on account of His virtue, as said above, but
essentially, even as the synod
said, ‘He is of no other essence’ but of the
Father’s, to whom these prerogatives are proper. But what can
that be which is proper to the Father’s essence, and an offspring
from it, or what name can we give it, save ‘coessential?’
For that which a man sees in the Father, that sees he also in the Son;
and that not by participation, but essentially. And this is [the
meaning of] ‘I and the Father are one,’ and ‘he that
hath seen Me hath seen the Father.’ Here especially once more it
is easy to shew their folly. If it is from virtue, the antecedent of
willing and not willing, and of moral progress, that you hold the Son
to be like the Father; while these things fall under the category of
quality; clearly you call God compound of quality and essence. But who
will tolerate you when you say this? For God, who compounded all things
to give them being, is not compound, nor of similar nature to the
things made by Him through the Word. Far be the thought. For He is
simple essence, in which quality is not, nor, as James says, ‘any
variableness or shadow of turning James i. 17..’
Accordingly, if it is shewn that it is not from virtue (for in God
there is no quality, neither is there in the Son), then He must be
proper to God’s essence. And this you will certainly admit if
mental apprehension is not utterly destroyed in you. But what is that
which is proper to and identical with the essence of God, and an
Offspring from it by nature, if not by this very fact coessential with
Him that begat it? For this is the distinctive relation of a Son to a
Father, and he who denies this, does not hold that the Word is Son in
nature and in truth.