The illogicality of Arianism has often been
pointed out (Gwatkin, pp. 21 sqq. esp. p. 28); how, starting
from the Sonship of Christ, it came round to a denial of His Sonship;
how it started with an interest for Monotheism and landed in a
vindication of polytheism; how it began from the incomprehensibility of
God even to His Son, and ended (in its most pronounced form) with the
assertion that the divine Nature is no mystery at all, even to us. It
is an insult to the memory of Aristotle to call such shallow hasty
syllogising from ill-selected and unsifted first principles by his
name. Aristotle himself teaches a higher logic than this. But at this
date Aristotelianism proper was extinct. It only survived in the form
of ‘pure’ logic, adopted by the Platonists, but also
studied for its own sake in connection with rhetoric and the art of
arguing (cf. Socr. ii. 35). Such an instrument might well be a cause of
confusion in the hands of men who used it without regard to the
conditions of the subject-matter. An illogical compromise between the
theology of Paul of Samosata and of Origen, the marvel is that Arianism
satisfied any one even in the age of its birth. What has been said
above with regard to the conception of God in the early Church may help
to explain it; the germ of ethical insight which is latent in
adoptionism, and which when neglected by the Church has always made
itself felt by reaction, must also receive justice; once again, its
inherent intellectualism was in harmony with the dominant theology of
the Eastern Church, that is with one side of Origenism. Where analogous
conditions have prevailed, as for example in the England of the early
eighteenth century, Arianism has tended to reappear with no one of its
attendant incongruities missing.