The first suggestion of a new creed came from the
Arian bishops, who propounded a formula (p. 146, §22), with a
disavowal of any intention of disparaging that of Nicæa (Socr. ii.
10), but suspiciously akin to the evasive confession of Arius, and
prefaced with a suicidally worded protest against being considered as
followers of the latter. The fate of this creed in the council is
obscure; but it would seem to have failed to commend itself to the
majority, who put forward a creed alleged to have been composed by
Lucian the martyr. This (see above, p. xxviii, and p. 461, notes
5–9), was hardly true of the creed as it stood, but it may have
been signed by Lucian as a test when he made his peace with bishop
Cyril. At any rate the creed is catholic in asserting the exact
Likeness of the Son to the Father’s Essence (yet the Arians could
admit this as de facto true, though not originally so; only the
word Essence would, if honestly taken, fairly exclude their sense), but
anti-Nicene in omitting the ὁμοούσιον,
and in the phrase τῇ μὲν
ὑποστάσει
τρία, τῇ δὲ
συμφωνί& 139·
ἕν, an artfully chosen point of contact between
Origen on the one hand, and Asterius, Lucian, and Paul of Samosata on
the other. The anathemas, also, let in an Arian interpretation. This
creed is usually referred to as the ‘Creed of the
Dedication’ or ‘Lucianic’ Creed, and represents, on
the one hand the extreme limit of concession to which Arians were
willing to go, on the other the theological rallying point of the
gradually forming body of reasoned conservative opinion which under the
nickname of ‘semi-Arianism’ (Epiph. Hær. 73; it
was repudiated by Basil of Ancyra, &c.) gradually worked toward the
recognition of the Nicene formula.