Chapter III.
To the objection of the Arians, that two Gods are introduced by a unity of substance,
the answer is that a plurality of Gods is more likely to be inferred from diversity of substance.
Further, their charge recoils upon themselves. Manifold diversity is the reason why two men
cannot be said to be one man, though all men are called individually man, where a unity of
nature is referred to. There is one nature alone in them, but there is wholly a unity in the
Divine Persons. Therefore the Son is not to be severed from the Father, especially as they
dare not deny that worship is due to Him.
39. But the Arians maintain the following: If you say that, as the Father is the only true
God, so also is the Son, and confess that the Father and the Son are both of one substance,
you introduce not one God, but two. For they who are of one substance seem not to be one
God but two Gods. Just as two men or two sheep or more are spoken of, but a man and a
sheep are not spoken of as two men or two sheep, but as one man and one sheep.
40. This is what the Arians say; and by this cunning argument they attempt to catch the
more simple-minded. However if we read the divine Scriptures we shall find that plurality
occurs rather amongst those things which are of a diverse and different substance, that is,
ἑτερούσια. We have this set forth in the books of Solomon, in that passage in which he said:
“There are three things impossible to understand, yea, a fourth which I know not, the track
of an eagle in the air, the way of a serpent upon a rock, the path of a ship in the sea, and the
way of a man in his youth.”1784 An eagle and a ship and a serpent are not of one family and
nature, but of a distinguishable and different substance, and yet they are three. On the
testimony of Scripture, therefore, they learn that their arguments are against themselves.
41. Therefore, in saying that the substance of the Father and of the Son is diverse and
290
their Godhead distinguishable, they themselves assert there are two Gods. But we, when we
confess the Father and the Son, in declaring them still to be of one Godhead, say that there
are not two Gods, but one God. And this we establish by the word of the Lord. For where
there are several, there is a difference either of nature or of will and work. Lastly, that they
may be refuted on their own witness, two men are mentioned: But though they are of one
nature by right of birth, yet in time and thought and work and place, they are apart; and so
one man cannot be spoken of under the signification and number of two; for there is no
unity where there is diversity. But God is said to be one, and the glory and completeness of
the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit is thus expressed.
42. Such, indeed, is the truth of unity that, when the nature alone of human birth or of
human flesh is indicated, one man is the term used for the many, as it is written: “The Lord
is my helper, I will not fear what man can do unto me;”1785 that is, not the one person of a
1784 Prov. xxx. 18, 19.
1785 Ps. cxviii. 6.
Chapter III. To the objection of the Arians, that two Gods are introduced by a unity of substance, the answer is that a plurality of Gods is more likely to be inferred from diversity of substance. Further, their charge recoils upon themselves. Manifold diversity is the reason why two men cannot be said to be one man, though all men are called individually man, where a unity of nature is referred to. There is one nature alone in them, but there is wholly a unity in the Divine Persons. Therefore the Son is not to be severed from the Father, especially as they dare not deny that worship is due to Him.
643
Chapter III. To the objection of the Arians, that two Gods are introduced…