But that the research and
culture of our imposing author may be completely disclosed, we will
consider sentence by sentence his presentment of his sentiments.
“The Son,” he says, “does not appropriate the dignity
of the Existent,” giving the name of “dignity” to the
actual fact of being:—(with what propriety he knows how to adapt
words to things!)—and since He is “by reason of the
Father,” he says that He is alienated from Himself on the ground
that the essence which is supreme over Him attracts to itself the
conception of the Existent. This is much the same as if one were to say
that he who is bought for money, in so far as he is in his own
existence, is not the person bought, but the purchaser, inasmuch as his
essential personal existence is absorbed into the nature of him who has
acquired authority over him. Such are the lofty conceptions of our
divine: but what is the demonstration of his
statements?….“the Only-begotten,” he says,
“Himself ascribing to the Father the title due of right to Him
alone,” and then he introduces the point that the Father alone is
good. Where in this does the Son disclaim the title of
“Existent”? Yet this is what Eunomius is driving at when he
goes on word for word as follows:—“For He Who has taught us
that the appellation ‘good’ belongs to Him alone Who is the
cause of His own goodness and of all goodness, and is so at all times,
and Who refers to Him all good that has ever come into being, would be
slow to appropriate to Himself the authority over all things that have
come into being, and the title of ‘the Existent.’”
What has “authority” to do with the context? and how along
with this is the Son also alienated from the title of
“Existent”? But really I do not know what one ought rather
to do at this,—to laugh at the want of education, or to pity the
pernicious folly which it displays. For the expression, “His
own,” not employed according to the natural meaning, and as those
who know how to use language are wont to use it, attests his extensive
knowledge of the grammar of pronouns, which even little boys get up
with their masters without trouble, and his ridiculous wandering from
the subject to what has nothing to do either with his argument or with
the form of that argument, considered as syllogistic, namely, that the
Son has no share in the appellation of “Existent”—an
assertion adapted to his monstrous inventions Oehler’s punctuation is here apparently erroneous. The
position of συμπεραστικῷ
is peculiar and the general construction of the
passage a little obscure: but if the text is to be regarded as sound,
the meaning must be something like that here given.,—this and similar absurdities seem
combined together for the purpose of provoking laughter; so that it may
be that readers of the more careless sort experience some such
inclination, and are amused by the disjointedness of his arguments. But
that God the Word should not exist, or that He at all events should not
be good (and this is what Eunomius maintains when he says that He does
not “appropriate the title” of “Existent” and
“good”), and to make out that the authority over all things
that come into being does not belong to him,—this calls for our
tears, and for a wail of mourning.