This canon (which in the Prisca and the Isidorian
version stands as part of canon 11) deals, like it, with cases which
had arisen under the Eastern reign of Licinius, who having resolved to
“purge his army of all ardent Christians” (Mason,
Persec. of Diocl. p. 308), ordered his Christian officers to
sacrifice to the gods on pain of being cashiered (compare Euseb. H.
E. x. 8; Vit. Con. i. 54). It is to be observed here
that military life as such was not deemed unchristian. The case
of Cornelius was borne in mind. “We serve in your
armies,” says Tertullian, Apol. 42 (although later, as a
Montanist, he took a rigorist and fanatical view, De Cor. 11),
and compare the fact which underlies the tale of the “Thundering
Legion,”—the presence of Christians in the army of Marcus
Aurelius. It was the heathenish adjuncts to their calling which
often brought Christian soldiers to a stand (see Routh. Scr.
Opusc. i. 410), as when Marinus’ succession to a
centurionship was challenged on the ground that he could not sacrifice
to the gods (Euseb. H. E. vii. 15). Sometimes, indeed,
individual Christians thought like Maximilian in the Martyrology, who
absolutely refused to enlist, and on being told by the proconsul that
there were Christian soldiers in the imperial service, answered,
“Ipsi sciunt quod ipsis expediat” (Ruinart, Act.
Sanc. p. 341). But, says Bingham (Antiq. xi. 5,
10), “the ancient canons did not condemn the military life as a
vocation simply unlawful.…I believe there is no instance of any
man being refused baptism merely because he was a soldier, unless some
unlawful circumstance, such as idolatry, or the like, made the vocation
sinful.” After the victory of Constantine in the West, the
Council of Arles excommunicated those who in time of peace “threw
away their arms” (can. 2). In the case before us, some
Christian officers had at first stood firm under the trial imposed on
them by Licinius. They had been “called by grace” to
an act of self-sacrifice (the phrase is one which St. Augustine might
have used); and had shown “their eagerness at the outset”
(“primum suum ardorem,” Dionysius; Philo and Evarestus more
laxly, “primordia bona;” compare τὴν ἀγάπην
σου τὴν
πρώτην, Rev. ii. 4). Observe here how beautifully the
ideas of grace and free will are harmonized. These men had
responded to a Divine impulse: it might seem that they had
committed themselves to a noble course: they had cast aside the
“belts” which were their badge of office (compare the cases
of Valentinian and Valens, Soc. iii. 13, and of Benevolus throwing down
his belt at the feet of Justina, Soz. vii. 13). They had done, in
fact, just what Auxentius, one of Licinius’ notaries, had done
when, according to the graphic anecdote of Philostorgius (Fragm.
5), his master bade him place a bunch of grapes before a statue of
Bacchus in the palace-court; but their zeal, unlike his, proved to be
too impulsive—they reconsidered their position, and illustrated the maxim that in morals second
thoughts are not best (Butler, Serm. 7), by making
unworthy attempts—in some cases by bribery—to recover what
they had worthily resigned. (Observe the Grecised Latinism
βενεφικίοις
and compare the Latinisms of St. Mark, and others in Euseb. iii. 20,
vi. 40, x. 5.) This the Council describes in proverbial language,
probably borrowed from 2 Pet.
ii. 22, but, it is needless
to say, without intending to censure enlistment as such. They now
desired to be received to penance: accordingly they were ordered
to spend three years as Hearers, during which time “their
purpose, and the nature (εἶδος) of their
repentance” were to be carefully “examined.”
Again we see the earnest resolution of the Council to make discipline a
moral reality, and to prevent it from being turned into a formal
routine; to secure, as Rufinus’ abridgment expresses it, a
repentance “fructuosam et attentam.” If the penitents
were found to have “manifested their conversion by deeds, and not
in outward show (σχήματι), by awe,
and tears, and patience, and good works” (such, for instance,
Zonaras comments, as almsgiving according to ability), “it would
be then reasonable to admit them to a participation in the
prayers,” to the position of Consistentes, “with permission
also to the bishop to come to a yet more indulgent resolution
concerning them,” by admitting them to full communion. This
discretionary power of the bishop to dispense with part of a
penance-time is recognized in the fifth canon of Ancyra and the
sixteenth of Chalcedon, and mentioned by Basil, Epist. 217, c.
74. It was the basis of “indulgences” in their
original form (Bingham, xviii. 4, 9). But it was too possible
that some at least of these lapsi might take the whole affair
lightly, “with indifference” ἀδιαφόρως
—not seriously enough, as Hervetas renders—just as if, in
common parlance, it did not signify: the fourth Ancyrene canon
speaks of lapsi who partook of the idol-feast ἀδιαφόρως
as if it involved them in no sin (see below on Eph. 5, Chalc. 4).
It was possible that they might “deem” the outward form of
“entering the church” to stand in the narthex among the
Hearers (here, as in c. 8, 19, σχῆμα denotes an external
visible fact) sufficient to entitle them to the character of converted
penitents, while their conduct out of church was utterly lacking in
seriousness and self-humiliation. In that case there could be no
question of shortening their penance time, for they were not in a state
to benefit by indulgence: it would be, as the Roman Presbyters
wrote to Cyprian, and as he himself wrote to his own church, a
“mere covering over of the wound” (Epist. 30, 3), an
“injury” rather than “a kindness” (De
Lapsis, 16); they must therefore “by all means” go
through ten years as Kneelers, before they can become Consistentes.