This
date, coming from the common source of the Historia Acephala and
Festal Index (i.e. from the accredited Alexandrian chronology of
the period), must be accepted unless there is cogent proof of its
incorrectness. No such proof is offered: we have no positive
statement to the contrary, but only (1) the fact that the intrusion
of George is related, Apol. Fug. 6, immediately after an attack
on the great church, possibly the coup de main of Syrianus, but
more probably that of p. 290, note 9, without any hint of a long
interval. This is true, and if there were no evidence the other
way might justify a guess that George came in Lent, 356; but
no one would claim that the passage is conclusive by itself; (2) the
‘improbability’ of George delaying his arrival so long.
Improbability is a relative term; we know too little of George’s
consecration or movements to justify its use in the present connection.
All the evidence goes to shew that the court party were far from
sanguine as to the nature of his reception, and that their misgivings
were well-founded. The above considerations look very small when we
compare them with the mass of positive evidence the other way. (1.) The
civil Governor had changed: Maximus held the post on Feb. 8, 356
(Hist. Ar. 81, &c.), Cataphronius when the churches were
transferred to the party of George, see below, 6. (2.) The military
Commander had changed: Syrianus was replaced by Sebastian, who appears
just after the transfer of churches, Hist. Ar. 55–60 (Dr.
Bright in D.C.B. i. 194, note, seems to admit that Sebastian
belongs to a later date than the Lent of 356). (3.) The Wednesday (and
Thursday) of Hist. Ar. 55 were not ‘in Lent.’
They suit the data of Hist. Aceph. perfectly well. (4.) Had
George arrived before Easter 356, Athan. would have heard of it
‘in the Desert,’ Apol. Const. 27; but he has only
heard of his nomination ὠνομάσθη 28, probably from the letters given in §§30, 31). (5.)
The Letter to the Egyptian bishops was written from Libya or Cyrenaica,
when the coercion of the episcopate had begun: it postulates some time
since his expulsion, but George was then (§7) only in
contemplation. (6.) There is no evidence that the coup de main
of Syrianus was other than unpopular in the city. This was reported to
Const., who after the (Easter) outrages on the Virgins (Ap.
Const. 27; Hist. Ar. 48), and after the expulsion of
the sixteen bishops (Hist. Ar. 54, this was probably about
Easter, Ap. Const. 27) sent Heraclius (with the
‘discreditable’ letter), in whose company (Hist.
Ar. 55) the new Prefect Cataphronius first appears. This let
loose the refuse of the heathen population as described, ib.
55–60. (7.) Here the precise statement of the Hist. Aceph.
fits in exactly. The Presbyters and people of Ath. remained in
possession of the Churches until the arrival of the new Prefect,
with Count Heraclius, on June 10. (8.) Heraclius is expressly
called the precursor of George (p. 288) and is evidently sent to
disarm the reported hostility of the (even heathen) public to the
appointment. It may be added that if we are to take
‘probabilities’ into account, it is easier to imagine a
reason for a court nominee like George having been slow to take up a
dangerous post, than for the Alexandrian chronologists of the day
having invented a year’s interval when none had existed.
Montfaucon had already noticed that ‘a good deal must have
happened’ between the irruption of Syrianus and the entry of
George. The data of Athanasius are for the first time clearly explained
by the light thrown on them by the chroniclers. I should also have
urged the fact that the commemoration of George’s Pentecost
Martyrs on May 21 in the Roman Martyrology suits 357 and
not 356, had I succeeded in tracing the history of the entry, which
has, however, so far eluded my efforts.